Andre Onana at Manchester United: Statistical Breakdown of His Controversial Goalkeeping Legacy

A deep dive into Andre Onana's polarizing Manchester United career through stats, comparisons with club legends, and expert analysis of his performances.

Andre Onana in action for Manchester United

The Onana Debate: Performance Analysis

Former Manchester United midfielder Nemanja Matic recently ignited controversy by branding current goalkeeper Andre Onana as "one of the worst keepers" in the club's storied history. This bold claim has sparked intense debate among football analysts and fans alike.

Key Statistics for Onana (2023-present):

  • 93 appearances since £43.8m move from Inter Milan
  • 137 goals conceded (1.47 per game)
  • 23 clean sheets (9 in Premier League this season)
  • 3.4 saves per 90 minutes (highest among post-2003 keepers)
  • Concedes every 63 minutes (lowest ratio among United keepers)
Comparative Analysis with United Legends: Goalkeeper Saves/90 Clean Sheet % Minutes/Goal
Onana 3.4 24.7% 63
De Gea 2.8 35.4% 84
Van der Sar 2.5 48.4% 117
Schmeichel N/A 44.4% 106

Defensive Context Matters It's crucial to note Onana is playing behind what manager Ruben Amorim called "maybe the worst" United team in 147 years. The club currently sits 13th in the Premier League, yet Onana ranks:

  • 4th in clean sheets this season
  • 2nd in goals prevented (behind Jordan Pickford)
  • Commits fewer errors leading to goals than several rivals

The Trophy Argument Onana countered critics by highlighting his FA Cup triumph in his debut season: "At least I've lifted trophies with the greatest club in the world. Some can't say the same."

Expert Perspectives Former goalkeeping coach Eric Steele suggests: "Onana's sweeping abilities suit modern football, but United's chaotic defense exposes his weaknesses. The constant scrutiny at Old Trafford magnifies every mistake."

Looking Ahead With Europa League quarter-finals looming against Lyon (Matic's current club), Onana has a prime opportunity to silence critics. His Champions League experience with Inter could prove vital in continental competition.

Recommended Reading:

What to Read Next

Thomas Frank Embraces the Challenge: A New Era for Tottenham Hotspur
Football

Thomas Frank Embraces the Challenge: A New Era for Tottenham Hotspur

Thomas Frank discusses his long-term vision for Tottenham Hotspur, embracing the challenges and aiming for consistent success across all competitions.

Manchester United's Striker Hunt: Watkins and Sesko Lead the Charge
Football

Manchester United's Striker Hunt: Watkins and Sesko Lead the Charge

Manchester United is targeting Ollie Watkins and Benjamin Sesko as key striker reinforcements in the current transfer window.

Revolutionizing Football: Referee Body Cameras to Debut at Premier League Summer Series
Football

Revolutionizing Football: Referee Body Cameras to Debut at Premier League Summer Series

The Premier League is set to trial referee body cameras during the Summer Series, enhancing transparency and decision-making in football.

Luke Shaw Endorses Ruben Amorim's Rigorous Standards at Manchester United
Football

Luke Shaw Endorses Ruben Amorim's Rigorous Standards at Manchester United

Luke Shaw supports Ruben Amorim's strict approach to improving Manchester United's team culture, emphasizing the need for a positive and demanding environment.

Tottenham Eyes Bayern's Palhinha: Transfer Rumors and Premier League Moves
Football

Tottenham Eyes Bayern's Palhinha: Transfer Rumors and Premier League Moves

Tottenham is in talks to bring Joao Palhinha back to the Premier League from Bayern Munich, amidst other major transfer moves in the football world.

Manchester United Fan Admits Assaulting Jack Grealish After Heated Derby Clash
Football

Manchester United Fan Admits Assaulting Jack Grealish After Heated Derby Clash

A Manchester United fan admitted to slapping Jack Grealish after a heated exchange during the Manchester Derby, resulting in a football banning order.

Manchester City's £35m Valuation for James McAtee: Transfer Market Buzz
Football

Manchester City's £35m Valuation for James McAtee: Transfer Market Buzz

Manchester City has set a £35m price tag for James McAtee, sparking interest from top clubs. Explore the latest football transfer news and updates.

Manchester United Secures Bryan Mbeumo in a £65m Deal: A Game-Changer for the Red Devils
Football

Manchester United Secures Bryan Mbeumo in a £65m Deal: A Game-Changer for the Red Devils

Manchester United has finalized a £65m deal to sign Bryan Mbeumo from Brentford, marking a significant addition to their squad ahead of the new season.

Liverpool's Defensive Woes Continue as Wirtz Shines in First Start Against AC Milan
Football

Liverpool's Defensive Woes Continue as Wirtz Shines in First Start Against AC Milan

Liverpool's record signing Florian Wirtz made his first start in a 4-2 loss to AC Milan, highlighting defensive issues while showcasing Wirtz's potential.

Eddie Howe Confirms No Offers for Newcastle's Star Striker Alexander Isak
Football

Eddie Howe Confirms No Offers for Newcastle's Star Striker Alexander Isak

Eddie Howe confirms Newcastle United has not received any offers for star striker Alexander Isak, amidst transfer speculation.

Arsenal Targets Eze: Latest Transfer Gossip and Premier League Updates
Football

Arsenal Targets Eze: Latest Transfer Gossip and Premier League Updates

Arsenal is set to approach Crystal Palace for Eberechi Eze, while Liverpool and Manchester United make their moves in the latest transfer gossip.

Premier League Stars Set to Shine at Afcon 2025: Key Players and Club Impacts
Football

Premier League Stars Set to Shine at Afcon 2025: Key Players and Club Impacts

Explore how Premier League stars like Mohamed Salah and Bryan Mbuemo will impact their clubs while competing at Afcon 2025 in Morocco.

Why Liam Delap Chose Chelsea: A New Chapter in His Football Career
Football

Why Liam Delap Chose Chelsea: A New Chapter in His Football Career

Liam Delap reveals why he chose Chelsea over other clubs, discussing the club's project, familiar faces, and his aspirations for the future.

Tottenham Hotspur Bolsters Defense with £5m Signing of Japanese Star Kota Takai
Football

Tottenham Hotspur Bolsters Defense with £5m Signing of Japanese Star Kota Takai

Tottenham Hotspur secures Japanese defender Kota Takai from Kawasaki Frontale for £5m, strengthening their squad with a promising young talent.

Manchester United's Transfer Turmoil: The Unwanted Five and the Road Ahead
Football

Manchester United's Transfer Turmoil: The Unwanted Five and the Road Ahead

Explore the ongoing transfer saga at Manchester United, focusing on the 'bomb squad' and their impact on the club's future plans.

Load More

We use essential cookies to make our site work. With your consent, we may also use non-essential cookies to improve user experience and analyze website traffic. By clicking "Accept," you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy.