Top MLB Prop Bets for the 2025 Season: Expert Picks for Every Team

With the 2025 MLB regular season just around the corner, excitement is building among baseball fans. The season kicks off on March 18 as the Los Angeles Dodgers, reigning champions, face the Chicago Cubs in Tokyo. For the rest of the league, the action starts on March 27 and 28. Predicting which players will shine this year is no easy task, but our team of experts has analyzed the odds and identified standout prop bets for each team.

American League

New York Yankees

• Prop Bet: To make the playoffs: No (+280)
  Despite their recent success, the Yankees face challenges this season with a weaker roster and aging veterans. Their division is highly competitive, making this bet a solid value.

Baltimore Orioles

• Prop Bet: Gunnar Henderson to win AL MVP (+750)
  With Aaron Judge as the favorite, Henderson stands out as a strong contender if the Orioles clinch the AL East. His elite performance in both offense and defense makes him a prime candidate.

Boston Red Sox

• Prop Bet: Jarren Duran to steal 40+ bases (+300)
  After a strong 2024 season, Duran is poised to break the 40-stolen base mark, especially with the Red Sox's aggressive base-running strategy under Alex Cora.

Tampa Bay Rays

• Prop Bet: Junior Caminero to hit 30+ HRs (+225)
  The Rays' move to a hitter-friendly park enhances Caminero's chances of reaching the 30-HR milestone. His power potential makes this bet a great value.

Toronto Blue Jays

• Prop Bet: Vladimir Guerrero Jr. to lead MLB in hits (+1600)
  Vlad Jr. is projected to be among the league leaders in hits this season, making this a high-value bet for a player with star potential.

National League

Philadelphia Phillies

• Prop Bet: Aaron Nola over 172.5 strikeouts (Even)
  Nola’s consistency in strikeouts makes this a reliable bet, especially with his track record of exceeding 200 strikeouts in multiple seasons.

Atlanta Braves

• Prop Bet: Matt Olson over 32.5 home runs (-110)
  Olson’s power numbers are expected to rebound this season, and with the Braves’ lineup supporting him, he’s a strong candidate to surpass 32 home runs.

Los Angeles Dodgers

• Prop Bet: Mookie Betts to win NL MVP (+1200)
  While Shohei Ohtani is the favorite, Betts remains a top contender for MVP if he continues his elite performance. His value at this price is hard to ignore.

San Diego Padres

• Prop Bet: Dylan Cease to lead MLB in strikeouts (+1600)
  Cease’s combination of volume and elite strikeout ability makes him a top candidate to lead the league in strikeouts this season.

Arizona Diamondbacks

• Prop Bet: To win NL West (+1000)
  Despite the Dodgers’ dominance, the Diamondbacks’ improved roster makes them a strong value bet to win the division.

Conclusion

The 2025 MLB season promises plenty of excitement, and these prop bets offer a way to engage with the action. Whether you’re rooting for your favorite team or looking for value in the betting market, these expert picks provide a solid starting point.