2025 MLB Mid-Season Analysis: Struggles, Surprises, and What Lies Ahead

As we approach the midpoint of the 2025 MLB season, several teams and players are underperforming, raising questions about their future prospects. Here’s a closer look at some of the most notable disappointments and what they mean for the rest of the season.

Juan Soto’s Struggles with the New York Mets

Juan Soto, the New York Mets’ $765 million acquisition, has not lived up to expectations. With a batting line of .233/.361/.438, 11 home runs, and 30 RBIs in 60 games, Soto’s performance has been underwhelming. Despite some signs of bad luck, as indicated by his expected batting average of .299, Soto needs to turn things around quickly to justify his massive contract.

Baltimore Orioles’ Downfall

The Baltimore Orioles, coming off a strong 2023 season, are struggling mightily in 2025. With an injury-depleted rotation and key hitters underperforming, the Orioles are on pace for one of the most disappointing seasons in recent memory. Manager Brandon Hyde’s mid-May firing underscores the team’s dire situation.

Tanner Scott’s Decline

Tanner Scott, once one of the best relievers in baseball, has seen a significant drop in performance. With a 4.55 ERA and a .260 opponent batting average, Scott’s struggles are a concern for the Los Angeles Dodgers, who signed him to a four-year, $72 million deal.

Sandy Alcantara’s Comeback Woes

Sandy Alcantara, returning from Tommy John surgery, has been a shadow of his former self. With a 7.89 ERA and a -1.4 WAR, Alcantara’s struggles are particularly damaging to the Miami Marlins, who had hoped he would be a top trade target.

What Lies Ahead

While it’s still early in the season, these performances raise significant questions about the future for these teams and players. Can they turn things around, or are these struggles indicative of a longer-term decline? Only time will tell as the 2025 MLB season continues to unfold.