Goalkeeper Crisis at Man Utd: Onana vs De Gea Debate Heats Up After Costly Errors

Manchester United's goalkeeper, Andre Onana, is once again under scrutiny following a critical mistake in their recent Premier League match against Ipswich Town. Despite United's 3-2 victory, Onana's error led to an early Ipswich goal, reigniting discussions about his reliability compared to former United keeper David de Gea.

Onana's Struggles Continue

Onana, who joined United for £47m in 2023, has been inconsistent this season. His latest blunder occurred when he misjudged a situation outside his penalty area, gifting Jaden Philogene an easy goal. This adds to a series of errors that have undermined United's season.

Comparisons with De Gea

David de Gea, now with Fiorentina, left United after a stellar career marked by consistency. Statistics favor De Gea in shot-stopping, with a save percentage of 72% compared to Onana's 65%. De Gea has also not committed any major errors leading to goals this season, unlike Onana.

Tactical Challenges

Under new manager Ruben Amorim, United has shifted to a 3-4-3 formation, which has not helped defensive stability. Frequent changes in the lineup and defensive substitutions have not allowed Onana to build the necessary understanding with his back line.

Looking Ahead

Despite his struggles, Onana has also made crucial saves that have kept United in games. However, the pressure is mounting, and with a capable backup in Altay Bayindir, Onana's position might be at risk if his performance does not improve. The ongoing comparison with De Gea only adds to the scrutiny surrounding his role at Old Trafford.