2025 MLB Midseason Grades: A Comprehensive Review

As the 2025 MLB season crosses the 90-game mark, it's time to evaluate the performance of all 30 teams. From the dominant Detroit Tigers to the struggling Baltimore Orioles, here's a detailed breakdown of each team's midseason grade.

Detroit Tigers: A+

The Tigers have been the class of the league, boasting the best record in MLB. Tarik Skubal has led the charge, but the team's depth across the roster has been the key to their success. Javier Baez is having a remarkable comeback season, and former top picks Casey Mize and Spencer Torkelson are contributing significantly. With a deep farm system, the Tigers are well-positioned to make impactful moves at the trade deadline.

Houston Astros: A

Despite losing key players like Alex Bregman and Kyle Tucker, and dealing with Yordan Alvarez's injury, the Astros are thriving. Hunter Brown, Framber Valdez, and Jeremy Pena have stepped up, and rookie Cam Smith has been a revelation. The Astros are on track for their eighth straight division title.

Chicago Cubs: A-

The Cubs are on pace for their most wins since their 2016 World Series title. Pete Crow-Armstrong has broken out in a big way, and Seiya Suzuki is delivering monster power numbers. However, injuries to Justin Steele and inconsistency in the rotation are concerns. The Cubs will look to bolster their pitching at the deadline.

Toronto Blue Jays: A-

The Blue Jays have surged to the top of the AL East, thanks to a remarkable 27-9 stretch. George Springer has rediscovered his peak form, and Addison Barger has been a force. While some stats suggest they’ve been lucky, the Blue Jays have the potential to improve further with Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Anthony Santander heating up.

Milwaukee Brewers: B+

The Brewers are succeeding with a balanced approach, led by All-Star Freddy Peralta. Brandon Woodruff returned strong from injury, and Jackson Chourio could be a key factor in the second half. If Chourio replicates his 2024 second-half performance, the Brewers could secure another postseason berth.

Tampa Bay Rays: B+

After a slow start, the Rays have clawed back into the AL East race. All-Stars Junior Caminero and Jonathan Aranda have been pivotal. However, a road-heavy schedule in July and August will test their pitching depth.

Los Angeles Dodgers: B

The Dodgers are on pace for 100 wins, despite underwhelming performances from Blake Snell and Roki Sasaki. Shohei Ohtani leads the NL in several categories, and Will Smith is batting .330. If the rotation gets healthy, the Dodgers remain World Series favorites.

Philadelphia Phillies: B

The Phillies are on track for 95 wins, largely due to their strong rotation. Zack Wheeler, Ranger Suarez, and Cristopher Sanchez have been outstanding. However, the bullpen has been inconsistent, and the offense lacks power beyond Kyle Schwarber. Expect the Phillies to add bullpen help and possibly an outfielder at the deadline.

St. Louis Cardinals: B

The Cardinals have been a pleasant surprise, but their offense is fading. Brendan Donovan is their lone All-Star, and the rotation lacks strikeout power. The Cardinals may struggle to maintain their current pace in the second half.

San Francisco Giants: B

The Giants started strong but have leveled off. Logan Webb and Robbie Ray have been excellent, but the offense needs more from Rafael Devers. A crucial series against the Dodgers before the All-Star break could determine their fate.

New York Mets: B

The Mets were the best team in baseball through June 12, but injuries to the rotation have derailed their momentum. Juan Soto has finally heated up, but the Mets need more from Mark Vientos and their catchers. Health will be key in the second half.

Seattle Mariners: B

Cal Raleigh has been a one-man show, but Julio Rodriguez and the pitching staff need to step up. The Mariners just swept the Pirates in three shutouts, which could be a turning point for their rotation.

Los Angeles Angels: B-

The Angels are hanging around .500, exceeding preseason expectations. They lead the majors in home runs and have used just five starting pitchers. However, their run differential suggests they’ve been fortunate.

San Diego Padres: B-

The Padres have struggled against top teams but have feasted on weaker opponents. Yu Darvish just made his season debut, which could provide a boost. The Padres need more from Dylan Cease and Michael King to stay in contention.

Cincinnati Reds: C+

The Reds are stuck in neutral, with a rotation that hasn’t clicked. Andrew Abbott has been a bright spot, but the Reds need Hunter Greene and Chase Burns to step up. A strong second half could put them in playoff contention.

New York Yankees: C

The Yankees have hit their annual midseason swoon, dropping from first place in the AL East. The offense has cooled off, and injuries to Clarke Schmidt and Gerrit Cole are concerning. The Yankees will need to make moves at the deadline to stay in the race.

Miami Marlins: C

The Marlins have been a surprise offensively, but their rotation has been a disaster. Sandy Alcantara has struggled, and the Marlins will need to address their pitching to stay competitive.

Arizona Diamondbacks: C

The Diamondbacks’ pitching has been a major issue, despite a strong offense. Corbin Burnes is out for the season, and Zac Gallen has been inconsistent. The Diamondbacks need a hot streak to stay in the playoff race.

Boston Red Sox: C-

The Red Sox have been a soap opera, with the Rafael Devers trade dominating headlines. The rookie trio of Kristian Campbell, Roman Anthony, and Marcelo Mayer hasn’t lived up to expectations. A tough schedule out of the All-Star break will test the Red Sox.

Kansas City Royals: C-

The Royals have struggled offensively, despite Bobby Witt Jr.’s strong performance. Jac Caglianone has been rushed to the majors and may need more time in Triple-A. The Royals could trade a starter for offensive help.

Chicago White Sox: C-

The White Sox are on pace for another 100-loss season, but their young pitchers have shown promise. Luis Robert Jr. has been unproductive, and Andrew Vaughn was traded to the Brewers. The White Sox are in full rebuild mode.

Minnesota Twins: D+

The Twins have underachieved, despite a 13-game winning streak. The Tigers have passed them in talent, and the Twins need a strong second half to stay in contention.

Pittsburgh Pirates: D+

The Pirates have been bad, despite Paul Skenes’ brilliance. They recently had a historic six-game stretch, but followed it with three straight shutout losses. The Pirates need more consistency to avoid another losing season.

Texas Rangers: D+

The Rangers have struggled to score runs, despite Jacob deGrom’s dominance. The 2023 World Series looks like a fluke, and the Rangers need a strong second half to stay in the playoff race.

Washington Nationals: D

The Nationals have received strong performances from James Wood and MacKenzie Gore, but their pitching has been a disaster. The firing of GM Mike Rizzo and manager Dave Martinez signals a need for organizational change.

Cleveland Guardians: D-

The Guardians have been shut out 11 times and are on a 10-game losing streak. The offense has been abysmal, and the bullpen has regressed. The Guardians’ season looks lost.

Oakland Athletics: D-

The Athletics have been a disaster, both on and off the field. Jacob Wilson and Nick Kurtz have been bright spots, but the team is drawing poorly in Sacramento. The A’s need to focus on building for the future.

Atlanta Braves: F

The Braves have been the biggest disappointment in the National League. The offense has collapsed, and the pitching has been inconsistent. The Braves’ playoff streak is in serious jeopardy.

Baltimore Orioles: F

The Orioles have been one of the worst teams in baseball, with a struggling offense and pitching staff. They will be sellers at the trade deadline and need to rebuild for the future.

Colorado Rockies: F

The Rockies have been historically bad, despite drawing large crowds. The promotion of Walker Monfort to executive VP signals a need for organizational change. The Rockies need to focus on building a competitive team.