MLB Playoff Power Rankings: Top Contenders and Sleepers for October 2025
Discover the top MLB teams to watch this October and the sleeper squads that could make a deep playoff run in the 2025 season.

The 2025 MLB playoffs are shaping up to be one of the most unpredictable in recent memory. With no team on pace to win 100 games, the field is wide open, and parity reigns supreme. Here’s a breakdown of the teams to beat in both the National League (NL) and American League (AL), along with the sleeper squads that could surprise everyone.
National League: The Brewers Lead the Pack
Milwaukee Brewers emerged as the NL’s team to beat, garnering 7 votes from players, executives, and scouts. Their balanced approach, deep starting rotation, and cohesive team play have been key to their success. However, the Philadelphia Phillies and Los Angeles Dodgers remain formidable threats. The Phillies boast a strong bullpen and playoff experience, while the Dodgers’ power-hitting lineup could carry them deep into October.
Biggest Threats to the Brewers
- Philadelphia Phillies: Known for their playoff pedigree and home run power, the Phillies could pose a significant challenge.
- Los Angeles Dodgers: With a healthy pitching staff and a potent offense, the Dodgers are always a threat in October.
Sleeper Teams in the NL
- San Diego Padres: Despite inconsistencies, their bullpen and deadline moves make them dangerous.
- New York Mets: If they can overcome their recent struggles, the Mets have the talent to make a run.
American League: The Blue Jays and Tigers Battle for Supremacy
In the AL, the Toronto Blue Jays edged out the competition with 6 votes. Their balanced lineup and home-field advantage at the newly renovated Rogers Centre make them a strong contender. The Detroit Tigers, led by ace Tarik Skubal, are also a team to watch, especially with their dominance at Comerica Park.
Biggest Threat to the Blue Jays
- Detroit Tigers: Their ability to dominate at home and Skubal’s presence on the mound make them a serious contender.
Sleeper Teams in the AL
- New York Yankees: With a powerful lineup and a bullpen that could heat up, the Yankees are always a threat.
- Houston Astros: The return of Yordan Alvarez and their playoff experience make them a dangerous wild card.
The Ultimate Sleeper: Seattle Mariners
The Seattle Mariners are the consensus sleeper pick. With a talented rotation and players built for the spotlight, they could be the team to watch if they get hot at the right time.
Conclusion
As October approaches, the 2025 MLB playoffs promise to be a thrilling spectacle. Whether it’s the Brewers, Blue Jays, or a sleeper team like the Mariners, the road to the World Series is wide open. Stay tuned for what could be one of the most exciting postseasons in recent history.