Optimizing MLB Pitching: A Deep Dive into Pitch Selection and Performance

Explore how MLB pitchers optimize their pitch selection using advanced analytics and game theory, highlighting the most and least balanced pitchers in the league.

Introduction

Pitching in Major League Baseball (MLB) is as much an art as it is a science. With the advent of advanced analytics, pitchers can now fine-tune their arsenals to maximize effectiveness. This article delves into the concept of Nash Scores, a metric rooted in game theory, to evaluate how pitchers are optimizing their pitch selection.

The Science Behind Pitch Selection

Modern pitchers rely on a combination of data and intuition to keep hitters guessing. The shape, spin, and velocity of each pitch are meticulously analyzed to create a repertoire that can confound even the best hitters. However, despite this sophistication, inefficiencies in pitch deployment can still exist.

Understanding Nash Scores

The Nash Score, named after the Nash equilibrium in game theory, compares the runs a pitcher saves with each pitch to the average runs saved by all of his other pitches combined. A low Nash Score indicates a balanced pitch mix, while a high score suggests potential inefficiencies.

Top Optimized Starters

Here are the top 15 starters who have achieved the greatest balance in their pitch selection over the past three seasons:

Pitcher Team(s) WAR Nash Score No. 1 Pitch No. 2 Pitch
Jake Irvin WSN 4.1 0.05 4-Seam FB (35%), +0.13 Curveball (33%), -0.13
Garrett Crochet CHW, BOS 6.7 0.06 4-Seam FB (49%), -0.14 Cutter (28%), +0.18
Kutter Crawford BOS 4.6 0.09 4-Seam FB (35%), -0.11 Cutter (31%), +0.43
Jesus Luzardo MIA, PHI 6.4 0.11 4-Seam FB (40%), -0.20 Slider (32%), +0.46
Ryan Pepiot LAD, TBR 4.3 0.11 4-Seam FB (48%), +0.32 Changeup (24%), -0.37
Freddy Peralta MIL 7.3 0.15 4-Seam FB (55%), +0.08 Changeup (18%), +0.67
Taj Bradley TBR 1.8 0.21 4-Seam FB (43%), -0.57 Cutter (22%), +0.22
Taijuan Walker PHI 1.8 0.25 Splitter (26%), -0.57 Sinker (23%), -0.16
Corbin Burnes MIL, BAL, ARI 9.2 0.34 Cutter (50%), +0.57 Curveball (20%), +0.03
MacKenzie Gore WSN 6.1 0.36 4-Seam FB (54%), +0.04 Curveball (21%), +0.31
Tarik Skubal DET 12.5 0.37 4-Seam FB (32%), -0.05 Changeup (28%), +0.62
Justin Verlander HOU, NYM, SFG 3.9 0.39 4-Seam FB (49%), -0.09 Slider (25%), +0.94
Nathan Eovaldi TEX 8.2 0.41 4-Seam FB (35%), -0.30 Splitter (30%), +0.84
Jameson Taillon CHC 4.2 0.42 4-Seam FB (34%), -0.48 Cutter (20%), +0.44
Reese Olson DET 4.5 0.42 Slider (27%), +0.47 Sinker (24%), +0.15

Top Optimized Relievers

Relievers often have simpler repertoires, making it easier to achieve a balanced pitch mix. Here are the top 15 relievers who have excelled in this area:

Pitcher Team(s) WAR Nash Score No. 1 Pitch No. 2 Pitch
Paul Sewald ARI, SEA, CLE 1.2 0.01 4-Seam FB (58%), +0.05 Slider (41%), -0.06
Colin Poche TBR, WSN 1.2 0.01 4-Seam FB (68%), +0.11 Slider (32%), -0.11
Tanner Scott MIA, SDP, LAD 6.2 0.03 4-Seam FB (56%), -0.14 Slider (44%), +0.15
Joe Jimenez ATL 2.5 0.03 4-Seam FB (51%), -0.06 Slider (44%), -0.08
Alexis Díaz CIN 1.6 0.03 4-Seam FB (56%), -0.18 Slider (44%), +0.18
Orion Kerkering PHI 1.8 0.03 Slider (56%), +0.06 4-Seam FB (28%), -0.26
A.J. Minter ATL, NYM 2 0.08 4-Seam FB (46%), -0.02 Cutter (39%), +0.30
Elvis Peguero MIL 1.1 0.08 Slider (50%), +0.27 Sinker (50%), -0.26
Brad Keller KCR, BOS, CHW, CHC 0.6 0.09 4-Seam FB (39%), +0.07 Slider (37%), +0.07
Edwin Diaz NYM 1.6 0.1 4-Seam FB (52%), +0.31 Slider (48%), -0.31
Jeremiah Estrada CHC, SDP 1.6 0.1 4-Seam FB (61%), -0.10 Slider (20%), -0.36
Kyle Finnegan WSN 2 0.12 4-Seam FB (68%), +0.31 Splitter (28%), -0.10
Luis Garcia SDP, BOS, LAA, LAD 0 0.12 Sinker (45%), -0.32 Slider (29%), -0.05
Ryan Walker SFG 3.1 0.15 Sinker (55%), +0.07 Slider (44%), +0.01
Craig Kimbrel PHI, BAL, ATL 0.8 0.15 4-Seam FB (66%), +0.26 Kn. Curve (30%), -0.37

Conclusion

Nash Scores provide a unique lens through which to view pitcher performance. By analyzing pitch selection and effectiveness, we can identify pitchers who are maximizing their arsenals and those who may need to adjust their strategies. Whether you're a fan, analyst, or player, understanding these metrics can offer valuable insights into the complex world of MLB pitching.

What to Read Next

Unveiling MLB's Legendary Postseason Streaks: A Deep Dive into Baseball's Elite Teams
MLB

Unveiling MLB's Legendary Postseason Streaks: A Deep Dive into Baseball's Elite Teams

Explore the most impressive postseason streaks in MLB history, featuring the Los Angeles Dodgers, Atlanta Braves, and more. Discover the teams that have consistently dominated the playoffs.

Ultimate MLB Betting & Fantasy Baseball Lineup Guide for Tuesday: Expert Tips & Predictions
MLB

Ultimate MLB Betting & Fantasy Baseball Lineup Guide for Tuesday: Expert Tips & Predictions

Get expert MLB betting tips and fantasy baseball lineup advice for Tuesday's games. Optimize your picks with detailed pitcher rankings and betting insights.

Mets' Playoff Hopes Hang in the Balance: Analyzing Their Struggles and Potential Turnaround
MLB

Mets' Playoff Hopes Hang in the Balance: Analyzing Their Struggles and Potential Turnaround

The New York Mets face a critical juncture in their season as they battle to secure a playoff spot amidst a series of setbacks.

MLB Playoff Power Rankings: Top Contenders and Sleepers for October 2025
MLB

MLB Playoff Power Rankings: Top Contenders and Sleepers for October 2025

Discover the top MLB teams to watch this October and the sleeper squads that could make a deep playoff run in the 2025 season.

Ultimate MLB Fantasy Baseball & Betting Guide: Monday's Top Picks & Strategies
MLB

Ultimate MLB Fantasy Baseball & Betting Guide: Monday's Top Picks & Strategies

Get expert advice on setting your fantasy baseball lineups and placing MLB bets for Monday's games. Includes top pitcher and hitter matchups, betting tips, and streaming options.

Moises Ballesteros Hits First MLB Home Run to Anthony Rizzo's Section in a Memorable Wrigley Field Moment
MLB

Moises Ballesteros Hits First MLB Home Run to Anthony Rizzo's Section in a Memorable Wrigley Field Moment

Moises Ballesteros hits his first MLB home run, nearly caught by Anthony Rizzo during a special ceremony at Wrigley Field.

Joey Chestnut's 99 Nuggets Challenge: A Legendary Feat at Dodgers-Giants Game
MLB

Joey Chestnut's 99 Nuggets Challenge: A Legendary Feat at Dodgers-Giants Game

Joey Chestnut takes on a new challenge: eating 99 Impossible Foods nuggets in nine innings at the Dodgers-Giants game. A must-watch event!

MLB Free Agency 2025: Projecting Kyle Tucker and Kyle Schwarber's Contracts
MLB

MLB Free Agency 2025: Projecting Kyle Tucker and Kyle Schwarber's Contracts

Insights into the potential contracts for Kyle Tucker and Kyle Schwarber in the 2025 MLB free agency, based on industry predictions.

Walker Buehler's Phillies Debut: A Return to the Majors and a Critique of Robot Umps
MLB

Walker Buehler's Phillies Debut: A Return to the Majors and a Critique of Robot Umps

Walker Buehler makes his Phillies debut, expressing concerns about the Automated Ball-Strike System while aiming to contribute to the team's World Series pursuit.

Ultimate MLB Fantasy Baseball and Betting Guide for Friday's Games
MLB

Ultimate MLB Fantasy Baseball and Betting Guide for Friday's Games

Get expert MLB fantasy baseball lineup advice and betting tips for Friday's games. Optimize your fantasy team and make informed bets with our comprehensive guide.

The Aaron Judge Effect: Pitchers Share Their Most Memorable Encounters with the Yankees' Powerhouse
MLB

The Aaron Judge Effect: Pitchers Share Their Most Memorable Encounters with the Yankees' Powerhouse

Discover the unforgettable moments pitchers have faced when going head-to-head with Aaron Judge, the New York Yankees' towering slugger.

2025 MLB September Power Rankings: Playoff Contenders and Pretenders
MLB

2025 MLB September Power Rankings: Playoff Contenders and Pretenders

Explore the latest MLB Power Rankings as teams jockey for position in the 2025 playoff race. Discover which teams are rising and which are falling in the crucial September stretch.

Luis Garcia's Comeback Cut Short: Astros Pitcher Returns to IL with Elbow Discomfort
MLB

Luis Garcia's Comeback Cut Short: Astros Pitcher Returns to IL with Elbow Discomfort

Houston Astros pitcher Luis Garcia is back on the 15-day injured list due to right elbow discomfort, just days after his return from Tommy John surgery.

Ultimate MLB Fantasy Baseball and Betting Guide for Thursday's Games
MLB

Ultimate MLB Fantasy Baseball and Betting Guide for Thursday's Games

Get expert advice on setting your fantasy baseball lineups and placing smart MLB bets for Thursday's games. Includes pitcher rankings, hitter insights, and betting tips.

2025 MLB Awards Race: MVP, Cy Young, and Rookie of the Year Predictions
MLB

2025 MLB Awards Race: MVP, Cy Young, and Rookie of the Year Predictions

As the 2025 MLB season nears its end, we analyze the tight races for MVP, Cy Young, and Rookie of the Year, with predictions and key insights.

Load More

We use essential cookies to make our site work. With your consent, we may also use non-essential cookies to improve user experience and analyze website traffic. By clicking "Accept," you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy.