Jacksonville Jaguars' Draft Strategy 2025: Defensive Reinforcements or Offensive Firepower at No. 5?

Jaguars' Draft Focus: Strengthening the Core

The Jacksonville Jaguars have made significant moves in free agency, but their roster still has critical gaps that must be addressed in the 2025 NFL Draft. With the No. 5 overall pick, the team faces a pivotal decision: bolster their defensive front or add dynamic playmakers to support quarterback Trevor Lawrence.

Key Areas of Need

1. Defensive Tackle – The Jaguars struggled with interior pass rush last season, and Mason Graham (Michigan) could be the disruptive force they need. Graham’s ability to pressure QBs and stop runs fits GM James Gladstone’s emphasis on "creating chaos."
2. Offensive Tackle – If the Jaguars prioritize protecting Lawrence, Will Campbell (LSU) or Armand Membou (Missouri) could compete with Walker Little and Anton Harrison.
3. Running Back – Ashton Jeanty (Boise State) offers a bruising style to complement Travis Etienne Jr., especially with Etienne’s contract uncertainty.
4. Wide Receiver – Adding speed with Matthew Golden (4.29s 40-yard dash) or size with Tetairoa McMillan (6'4") would enhance Lawrence’s weapons.

Defensive Strategy Under Liam Coen

Jaguars head coach Liam Coen has set non-negotiable traits for draft picks:

• Mental and physical toughness
• High football IQ and relentless effort

Potential fits:

• Abdul Carter (EDGE, Penn State) – If available, he’d instantly upgrade the pass rush.
• Will Johnson (CB, Michigan) – A shutdown cornerback to pair with Tyson Campbell.

Impact of Free Agency Signings

Jacksonville’s free agency moves addressed immediate needs:

• OL Patrick Mekari & Robert Hainsey – Solidified the interior line.
• S Eric Murray & CB Jourdan Lewis – Strengthened secondary depth.

Yet, the defensive line and offensive weapons still require top-tier talent infusion.

Projected First-Round Scenarios

• Best-Case: Travis Hunter (CB/WR, Colorado) falls to No. 5, giving the Jags a two-way playmaker.
• Likely Pick: Mason Graham (DT, Michigan) – Disruptive interior presence.
• Wildcard: Tetairoa McMillan (WR, Arizona) – A contested-catch monster beside Brian Thomas Jr.

Final Thoughts

The Jaguars' draft approach hinges on their long-term vision: building a strong defense or maximizing Trevor Lawrence’s potential. Either way, the No. 5 pick will define their 2025 season trajectory.