Sexism in Football: The Controversy Over Foden Chants and FA Inaction

The Incident at Old Trafford

Anti-discrimination charity Kick It Out condemned the sexist chants directed at Phil Foden's mother during the Manchester derby at Old Trafford. The derogatory chants were audible throughout the first half and when Foden was substituted in the 57th minute.

Pep Guardiola, Manchester City’s manager, criticized the behavior, calling it 'a lack of class' and stating those responsible 'should be ashamed.'

Kick It Out's Response

Hollie Varney, Chief Operating Officer of Kick It Out, emphasized:

"Sexism isn't 'banter'. Hearing sexist chants in stadiums creates an environment where women feel unsafe and unwelcome. Despite multiple incidents this season, football’s response remains inadequate."

She also highlighted research showing 85% of women who witnessed or experienced sexism in football did not report it, fearing inaction or dismissal.

FA Rules and Their Enforcement

The Football Association (FA) prohibits abusive chanting under Rule E20, which holds clubs accountable for discriminatory behavior by fans, including references to gender, race, or sexual orientation.

However, in this case, no action was taken. The FA stated that while offensive, the chants did not breach regulations because they were directed at a non-participant (Foden’s mother) rather than a player.

Recent Precedents:

• Millwall fans chanted "let him die" at Crystal Palace’s Jean-Philippe Mateta without FA punishment.
• Rebekah Vardy faced offensive chants after the 'Wagatha Christie' trial.
• Bruno Fernandes has been targeted with appearance-related insults.

The FA assesses incidents individually, but unless the case is extreme, charges are unlikely.

The Debate: Tradition vs. Accountability

Against the Chants:

• Pep Guardiola, Kick It Out, and others argue such behavior has no place in modern football.
• Clubs have tools to address misconduct (bans, fines, education), but enforcement remains inconsistent.

Defending 'Part of the Game' Mentality:

• Troy Deeney, former Watford striker, admitted:

  "It's unfortunate, but it’s part of football. I’ve heard worse about my family. We’re almost expected to tolerate it."

• Some fans argue emotional rivalries fuel such behavior, though critics counter that tradition shouldn’t excuse harm.

United's Stance

Manchester United privately acknowledged the chants were unacceptable but declined public comment.

Moving Forward

The incident raises questions:

1. Should FA regulations extend to non-participant targets of abuse?
2. How can clubs better combat discriminatory behavior?
3. Will governing bodies enforce stricter punishments long-term?

As debates continue, one thing is clear: sexism in football remains a pressing issue.