British & Irish Lions 2025: Why Caelan Doris Leads Maro Itoje in Captaincy Race
Analysis of the Lions captaincy battle between Caelan Doris and Maro Itoje ahead of the 2025 Australia tour, including squad selection debates.


Lions Captaincy Showdown: Doris vs Itoje
Former Lions winger Tommy Seymour has tipped Ireland's Caelan Doris as the frontrunner for 2025 British & Irish Lions captaincy over England's Maro Itoje. The decision, to be announced on 8 May, could hinge on Doris' established relationship with head coach Andy Farrell from their Ireland tenure.
Key Factors in Selection
-
Existing Coach-Player Dynamic: Seymour emphasizes the importance of instant messaging coherence: "From a preparation viewpoint, that connection between captain and coach is critical with limited preparation time."
-
Six Nations Performances: While Itoje impressed leading England to second place, Doris' consistent leadership for Ireland and Leinster gives him the edge according to analysts.
-
Personnel Integration: "Squad chemistry is crucial," Seymour notes. "Doris' experience under Farrell's system provides natural leadership transition."
Fly-Half Selection Controversy
The battle for the pivotal number 10 jersey intensifies with multiple contenders:
Player | Nation | Key Strengths |
---|---|---|
Finn Russell | Scotland | Creative playmaking |
Sam Prendergast | Ireland | Rising star, Champions Cup form |
Fin Smith | England | Consistent Six Nations |
Marcus Smith | England | Versatility (can play fullback) |
Former Ulster fly-half Ian Humphreys predicts: "Prendergast will start the first Test, with Russell and Fin Smith completing the trio. Marcus Smith's limited game time may cost him."
Wildcard Candidate
Owen Farrell remains an outside possibility despite his injury-disrupted season. His versatility and experience could prove valuable in a 36-man squad.
Tour Schedule Highlights
- July 19: First Test (Brisbane)
- July 26: Second Test (Melbourne)
- August 2: Third Test (Sydney)
The seven-week tour promises intense competition as Farrell builds a squad capable of their first series win since 2013.