FA Cup Fifth Round Showdown: Sutton vs. Widdicombe’s Predictions and Premier League Drama

As the FA Cup reaches its fifth round, the excitement is palpable, and football expert Chris Sutton is back with his predictions, this time facing off against comedian and Plymouth fan Josh Widdicombe. The stage is set for some thrilling encounters, with Premier League heavyweights and Championship underdogs battling for a place in the quarter-finals.

Key Matches to Watch

Manchester City vs. Plymouth Argyle

Plymouth has already caused upsets this season, knocking out Brentford and Liverpool. However, facing Manchester City is a whole different challenge. Sutton notes, "Plymouth's direct style under new manager Miron Muslic contrasts sharply with Pep Guardiola's possession-based football. But giving City the ball back repeatedly could spell trouble."

Widdicombe, though a die-hard Plymouth fan, remains pessimistic: "City were the worst possible draw. I’d take penalties now, even though I’ll be on stage during injury time!" Sutton predicts a 5-0 victory for City, while Widdicombe foresees a 4-0 loss.

Aston Villa vs. Cardiff City

Aston Villa, juggling Champions League commitments and Premier League ambitions, face Championship strugglers Cardiff. Sutton expects Villa to dominate: "Cardiff are pretty hopeless on the road. Even with squad rotations, Villa should be too strong." Sutton predicts a 3-1 win, with Widdicombe concurring on a 3-0 scoreline.

Newcastle vs. Brighton

Newcastle, still reeling from Alexander Isak’s injury, face a resurgent Brighton. Sutton believes Newcastle’s domestic cup double dream could stay alive: "Brighton won at St James’ Park earlier this season, but history doesn’t often repeat itself." He predicts a 3-2 win for Newcastle after extra time, while Widdicombe is less optimistic, predicting a 1-2 loss.

Underdog Stories and Iconic Moments

Widdicombe reminisces about the FA Cup’s golden era in the 1990s: "The FA Cup isn’t as important as it used to be, but those one-off moments are what you cling to. Plymouth’s win over Liverpool will forever be etched in my memory."

Conclusion

With no replays this year, matches will be decided by extra time and penalties, adding to the drama. Sutton and Widdicombe’s differing perspectives offer a mix of expert analysis and fan passion, making this FA Cup round one to remember.