The Rise and Fall of Warren Gatland: A Cautionary Tale in Welsh Rugby

The Legacy of Warren Gatland

Warren Gatland, one of the most respected figures in international rugby, took on the head coach role for Wales not once but twice. His first tenure from 2007 to 2019 was marked by unprecedented success, including three Grand Slam victories in the Six Nations and two Rugby World Cup semi-final appearances. His leadership also saw Wales briefly top the world rankings in 2019. However, his return in December 2022 painted a starkly different picture.

A Second Spell Gone Wrong

Gatland’s second stint as Wales head coach coincided with one of the most challenging periods in Welsh rugby history. The team suffered a record 14 consecutive Test losses, with only six wins in 26 matches. This dramatic downturn led to Wales statistically becoming their worst-performing side in 144 years of international rugby. The contrast between Gatland’s two spells is striking: from a 56% success rate in his first tenure to less than 25% in his second.

Challenges and Controversies

Gatland faced numerous challenges during his second tenure, including internal strife within the Welsh Rugby Union (WRU) and player contract disputes that nearly led to a strike during the 2023 Six Nations. Additionally, allegations of sexism and misogyny within the WRU surfaced, further destabilizing the team’s environment. Despite these obstacles, Gatland managed to guide Wales to a memorable victory over Australia at the 2023 Rugby World Cup, though they were ultimately eliminated in the quarter-finals by Argentina.

The Fallout

By 2025, Gatland’s position had become untenable. Wales endured a humiliating 43-0 loss to France in the opening game of the Six Nations, marking the first time they had failed to score under his leadership. A subsequent defeat to Italy sealed his fate, and Gatland stepped down, leaving behind a team in disarray. While his legacy as one of Wales’ greatest coaches remains intact, his second tenure has undeniably tarnished his reputation.

Lessons Learned

Gatland’s story serves as a cautionary tale about the risks of returning to a former role in sports. Despite his previous successes, the changing dynamics of Welsh rugby proved insurmountable. His experience highlights the importance of timing, leadership, and the challenges of rebuilding a team in decline. Gatland’s legacy will forever be remembered as both the architect of Wales’ golden era and the coach who presided over its darkest days.