Ryan Hardie's Redemption: Plymouth Argyle's Historic FA Cup Triumph Over Liverpool

Ryan Hardie overcomes past penalty heartbreak to lead Plymouth Argyle to a historic victory against Liverpool in the FA Cup.

From Heartbreak to Heroism

Ryan Hardie, Plymouth Argyle's Scottish striker, faced a moment of redemption in the FA Cup against Liverpool. Just three years after a crucial penalty miss against Chelsea, Hardie found himself in a similar situation but with a vastly different outcome.

The Weight of the Past

In 2022, Hardie's missed penalty at Stamford Bridge crushed Plymouth Argyle's hopes of an upset against Chelsea. The memory lingered, especially the night before the Liverpool match. "Last night I thought back to the Chelsea game and I thought 'oh my god, if we get a pen tomorrow what will happen if the same thing happens?'," Hardie admitted to BBC Sport.

The Moment of Truth

Facing Liverpool, Hardie was determined to rewrite his narrative. With the game on the line, he stepped up to take the penalty and this time, he made no mistake, firing past Caoimhin Kelleher to secure a historic 1-0 victory for Plymouth Argyle. "So now that I've got that bairn off my shoulder I'm happy," he said.

A Legacy Cemented

This victory wasn't just about the win; it was about the legacy. Hardie’s goal helped the Championship's bottom team, Plymouth Argyle, topple the Premier League leaders and Champions League group-stage winners Liverpool. "Today's going to be cemented in the club's history, the city's history and our names are going to be on that," Hardie expressed.

Emotional Rollercoaster

The day was extra special for Hardie as his son was the Pilgrims' mascot. "He came up on the screen doing a little interview and it set me off before the game, it brought tears to my eyes, it was a special, special moment," he shared.

Looking Ahead

This monumental win, often cited as Plymouth Argyle's greatest, sets a high bar for the team's future. Hardie's redemption arc adds a personal triumph to the collective achievement, marking a moment that will be remembered in the annals of football history.


FA Cup matches often bring out the best in underdog teams, and Plymouth Argyle's victory over Liverpool is a testament to the magic of the competition.

What to Read Next

Manchester Derby Secures Women's FA Cup Semi-Final Thriller: Man City vs. Man Utd Clash
Football

Manchester Derby Secures Women's FA Cup Semi-Final Thriller: Man City vs. Man Utd Clash

The Women's FA Cup heats up with Manchester City set to face Manchester United in the semi-finals, while Chelsea takes on Liverpool. Catch all the action live on the BBC.

PSG's Dominance Unrewarded: Luis Enrique Laments Unfair Outcome Against Liverpool
Football

PSG's Dominance Unrewarded: Luis Enrique Laments Unfair Outcome Against Liverpool

Despite a dominant performance, PSG fell to a narrow defeat against Liverpool in the Champions League, with Luis Enrique expressing his frustration over the unfair outcome.

Amber Whiteley: Steering Liverpool Women Through a Pivotal Era in the WSL
Football

Amber Whiteley: Steering Liverpool Women Through a Pivotal Era in the WSL

Amber Whiteley, Liverpool’s interim manager, aims to rejuvenate the team in the Women's Super League and lead them through a crucial FA Cup quarter-final.

Liverpool's Triple Final Challenge: A Season of High Stakes and Potential Glory
Football

Liverpool's Triple Final Challenge: A Season of High Stakes and Potential Glory

Explore Liverpool's pivotal season as they face three crucial finals, aiming for a historic treble under Arne Slot's leadership.

Alisson's Heroics: How Liverpool Escaped PSG's Onslaught in Champions League Thriller
Football

Alisson's Heroics: How Liverpool Escaped PSG's Onslaught in Champions League Thriller

Discover how Alisson's record-breaking performance saved Liverpool from PSG's dominance in a dramatic Champions League encounter.

Top 5 Spectacular Goals from FA Cup Fifth Round 2023
Football

Top 5 Spectacular Goals from FA Cup Fifth Round 2023

Explore the top 5 most spectacular goals from the FA Cup fifth round and vote for your favorite. A must-read for every football enthusiast!

Millwall Condemns Heinous Abuse Towards Liam Roberts Post-Mateta Incident in FA Cup Clash
Football

Millwall Condemns Heinous Abuse Towards Liam Roberts Post-Mateta Incident in FA Cup Clash

Millwall firmly denounces the vile abuse targeted at Liam Roberts following a contentious tackle in the FA Cup match against Crystal Palace.

Fulham Takes a Stand Against Racism: The Calvin Bassey Abuse Scandal
Football

Fulham Takes a Stand Against Racism: The Calvin Bassey Abuse Scandal

Fulham FC condemns the racist and homophobic abuse targeting Calvin Bassey after their FA Cup victory, emphasizing zero tolerance in sports.

Pep Guardiola and Miron Muslic's Post-Match Bond: A Tale of Fanta and Football
Football

Pep Guardiola and Miron Muslic's Post-Match Bond: A Tale of Fanta and Football

Discover how Pep Guardiola and Miron Muslic shared a post-match moment with Fanta, highlighting the camaraderie in football during Plymouth Argyle's FA Cup journey.

Guardiola Blames FA Cup Ball for Man City's Off-Target Shots: A Deep Dive
Football

Guardiola Blames FA Cup Ball for Man City's Off-Target Shots: A Deep Dive

Pep Guardiola voices concerns over the Mitre FA Cup ball's performance after Manchester City's 20 off-target shots in their recent match against Plymouth.

FA Cup Quarter-Finals: Premier League Giants and Championship Underdogs Clash for Glory
Football

FA Cup Quarter-Finals: Premier League Giants and Championship Underdogs Clash for Glory

Explore the thrilling FA Cup quarter-final matchups featuring Premier League leaders and Championship underdogs. Discover key games and historic opportunities.

Danny Welbeck's Inspiring Comeback: Brighton's Key to Success
Football

Danny Welbeck's Inspiring Comeback: Brighton's Key to Success

Discover how Danny Welbeck's resurgence has been pivotal for Brighton, driven by his exceptional form and 'good genes'.

Matheus Cunha's Red Card Fallout: A Turning Point for Wolverhampton Wanderers?
Football

Matheus Cunha's Red Card Fallout: A Turning Point for Wolverhampton Wanderers?

Explore the implications of Matheus Cunha's red card for Wolverhampton Wanderers in the FA Cup and its potential impact on their Premier League campaign.

Why the Eight-Minute Bournemouth VAR Check Sparked a Football Debate
Football

Why the Eight-Minute Bournemouth VAR Check Sparked a Football Debate

An in-depth look at the record-breaking eight-minute VAR stoppage during Bournemouth's FA Cup match against Wolves, exploring the implications for football technology.

Jean-Philippe Mateta Suffers Head Injury in FA Cup Clash After Keeper's Reckless Challenge
Football

Jean-Philippe Mateta Suffers Head Injury in FA Cup Clash After Keeper's Reckless Challenge

Crystal Palace's Jean-Philippe Mateta was stretchered off after a head injury caused by Millwall's goalkeeper Liam Roberts in a dramatic FA Cup match.

Load More