Sam Darnold's Rollercoaster: The Uncertainty of the Comeback Player Award

Sam Darnold's unexpected resurgence in the NFL has sparked controversy among bettors and voters regarding the Comeback Player of the Year award.

For six tumultuous seasons, Sam Darnold battled his way through the mediocrity of the NFL. Once a highly-touted top-five draft pick in 2018, Darnold's career was marred by lackluster performances during his tenure with the New York Jets and the Carolina Panthers, plus a forgettable year as a backup with the San Francisco 49ers.

When he signed with the Minnesota Vikings in 2024, expectations were low—especially after the young rookie quarterback, J.J. McCarthy, suffered a preseason injury, thrusting Darnold into the starting role. Notably absent from early MVP conversations, sportsbooks initially didn’t even list him, and those who did offered him odds as high as 300-1.

To everyone’s surprise, Darnold led the Vikings to an incredible 5-0 start, showcasing his talent with a completion rate of 65.9%, totaling 724 yards and nine touchdowns in key games against the 49ers, Texans, and Packers. His impressive String of performances led many bettors, including George "Riley" Panagakis, to believe he should be a frontrunner for the AP NFL Comeback Player of the Year award.

Confident in Darnold’s abilities, Panagakis placed a significant $1,000 wager on him at +1000 odds after Week 1, citing Darnold's high draft pedigree and surrounding talent at wide receiver. "I'm not just throwing darts; I'm making picks for reasoning, and I think he's a legitimate candidate," Panagakis reflected.

Darnold's trajectory mirrored that of the recent winners of the Comeback Player of the Year, particularly Seattle's Geno Smith and Joe Flacco of the Browns, both of whom turned their careers around spectacularly to lead their teams into the playoffs. However, contention arose around the ambiguous eligibility criteria outlined by the Associated Press, particularly the phrase: "other circumstances that led him to miss playing time the previous season." This sparked debate among voters.

While many sportsbooks fluctuated their odds throughout the season based on public sentiment—taking Darnold on and off the board—it became clear that he had garnered significant attention and betshare. At ESPN Bet, he accounted for 18.5% of total bets, highly competitive with other contenders like Joe Burrow, who ultimately closed as the favorite. Amidst mounting odds and minimum clarity on voter intentions, Darnold's betting line swayed dramatically, reflecting wider uncertainties inherent in award races.

The final decision on the Comeback Player of the Year remains precarious, hinging on how voters interpret the AP's new guidelines. While Burrow recorded an MVP-quality season, skeptics argue whether his minor injury hampers his narrative as dramatically as Darnold's perceived resurgence. As the impending NFL Honors approach, all eyes will be fixed on the outcome, with bettors anxiously awaiting to see whether Darnold, Burrow, J.K. Dobbins, or even Damar Hamlin will rise to the occasion.

Ultimately, the ambiguity surrounding the Comeback Player of the Year award is a fascinating exploration into the intertwining worlds of sports betting and human sentiment, an epicenter of disagreement that showcases the unpredictable nature of this beloved game.

What to Read Next

The New York Jets' Bold Offensive Line Strategy with Armand Membou
NFL

The New York Jets' Bold Offensive Line Strategy with Armand Membou

The New York Jets' focus on building a strong offensive line with Armand Membou and their draft decisions.

Dallas Cowboys' Struggles to Fill WR2 Position after 2025 NFL Draft
NFL

Dallas Cowboys' Struggles to Fill WR2 Position after 2025 NFL Draft

The Dallas Cowboys face challenges in finding a WR2 for Dak Prescott after the 2025 NFL draft.

The 2025 NFL Draft: Insights, Picks, and Future Prospects
NFL

The 2025 NFL Draft: Insights, Picks, and Future Prospects

Analysis of the 2025 NFL draft with picks, team performances, and future outlooks.

Cam Ward's Leadership Shines in Titans' Draft Rookies Interaction
NFL

Cam Ward's Leadership Shines in Titans' Draft Rookies Interaction

Cam Ward demonstrates leadership skills by connecting with Titans' draftees.

Bengals' Demetrius Knight Jr.: From Delivery Driver to NFL Prospect
NFL

Bengals' Demetrius Knight Jr.: From Delivery Driver to NFL Prospect

Demetrius Knight Jr. drafted by Bengals, reflecting on his journey from delivery work to NFL.

Matthew McConaughey's Enthusiastic Analysis of Texas Longhorns in NFL Draft
NFL

Matthew McConaughey's Enthusiastic Analysis of Texas Longhorns in NFL Draft

Actor Matthew McConaughey passionately comments on Texas Longhorns draftees.

Shedeur Sanders' NFL Draft Journey: From Wait to Cleveland Browns' Choice
NFL

Shedeur Sanders' NFL Draft Journey: From Wait to Cleveland Browns' Choice

Shedeur Sanders selected by the Browns in the 5th round, sparking diverse reactions.

Cowboys' Tyler Booker's Excitement and Challenges Ahead
NFL

Cowboys' Tyler Booker's Excitement and Challenges Ahead

Tyler Booker, Cowboys' draftee, is excited but faces challenges, including moving his pet turtle.

Detroit Lions Honor Brad Holmes with North Carolina A&T Jerseys Ahead of Commencement Speech
NFL

Detroit Lions Honor Brad Holmes with North Carolina A&T Jerseys Ahead of Commencement Speech

The Detroit Lions honor GM Brad Holmes with jerseys for his alma mater speech.

Saints' QB Decision: Shough's Arrival and Its Impact
NFL

Saints' QB Decision: Shough's Arrival and Its Impact

The Saints' draft pick of QB Tyler Shough raises questions and potential impacts.

Insights and Analysis of the 2025 NFL Draft
NFL

Insights and Analysis of the 2025 NFL Draft

In-depth coverage of the 2025 NFL Draft with analysis of every team's picks.

Jaxson Dart: The Future QB of the New York Giants
NFL

Jaxson Dart: The Future QB of the New York Giants

The New York Giants selected Jaxson Dart in the NFL draft. His potential and the team's plans.

The 2025 NFL Draft: Insights and Surprises
NFL

The 2025 NFL Draft: Insights and Surprises

Analysis of the 2025 NFL draft's first round with top picks, trades and more

The Bold Move of Jacksonville Jaguars for Travis Hunter in NFL Draft
NFL

The Bold Move of Jacksonville Jaguars for Travis Hunter in NFL Draft

The Jacksonville Jaguars made a bold draft move for Travis Hunter. Explore the details and impact.

2025 NFL Draft: Round 2 Insights and Prospects Predictions
NFL

2025 NFL Draft: Round 2 Insights and Prospects Predictions

Insights into Round 2 of the 2025 NFL Draft, with predictions for top prospects' landing spots.

Load More