Navigating the Quarterback Landscape: The Steelers' 2025 Dilemma

The Steelers' Quarterback Conundrum

The Pittsburgh Steelers find themselves once again at a pivotal juncture in their quarterback saga. With the departures of both Russell Wilson and Justin Fields looming as they enter the 2025 season, the Steelers' quarterback situation is far from secure. As team owner and president Art Rooney II expressed this week, choosing one of these talented QBs seems essential, but the idea of retaining both is nearly impossible.

Recent Statements from Rooney
Rooney acknowledged that while both quarterbacks envision themselves as starters, it’s unlikely the team will be able to accommodate their ambitions simultaneously. He stated, "I think both of them see themselves as starters, and I don't know that they want to share the same job again next year." With the limited options available in the upcoming draft and free agency, the Steelers must act decisively.

Potential Pathways for the Steelers

Adventure 1: Re-signing Justin Fields
In reviewing the journeys of both quarterbacks, re-signing Fields appears to be the more favorable option based on the Steelers' history and team dynamics. Fields showcased promise during his six starts, amassing a 4-2 record, yet there’s a clear belief within the organization that Fields has untapped potential. The coaching staff, particularly Head Coach Mike Tomlin, noted his impressive handling of pressure situations and consistent improvement.

Fields, age 25, is not only younger than Wilson but also more financially appealing given his potential earnings in the range of $10 million to $15 million annually. Such a deal would allow the Steelers to allocate funds elsewhere, particularly to their wide receiver corps, which currently faces uncertainty beyond 2025.

Adventure 2: Retaining Russell Wilson
Alternatively, the Steelers could opt to secure Wilson’s experience, especially considering his Super Bowl pedigree. Despite a decline in performance over the final stretch of the previous season, Wilson still has the ability to enhance the offense when supported adequately. However, his contract demands could limit the Steelers’ ability to pursue high-end free agents, particularly wide receivers, an area where the team needs substantial reinforcement.

Adventure 3: Going for a Franchise QB in the Draft
In what may seem like the boldest option, the Steelers could choose to snag a franchise quarterback in the first round while re-signing backup Kyle Allen. This strategy could echo their previous decision with Kenny Pickett, but they must learn from past mistakes to ensure a better outcome. With a strategic approach and a focus on building a coherent quarterback room, they could position a rookie for immediate success behind a competent offensive line.

Conclusion

As the offseason looms, the Steelers' decision may define their future trajectory for years to come. Each potential path carries its risks, and the choice between Fields and Wilson—or charting an entirely new course with a draft pick—will require keen insight and strategic foresight. With $37 million in cap space available, the Steelers are poised to make significant moves that could shape the franchise's fate.

The upcoming months will undeniably be a time of substantial reflection, analysis, and decision-making for Pittsburgh as they work to secure a reliable future at quarterback.