A Tale of Two Teams: The Dodgers and Their Brooklyn Offspring
Explore the thrilling hypothetical showdown between the Los Angeles Dodgers and their split-off Brooklyn Trolleys in the 2025 NLCS.

The Stage is Set
As the sun sets over Brooklyn on a beautiful autumn day, baseball fans find themselves at the iconic Ebbets Field, now resurrected for a clash of titans. The Los Angeles Dodgers, a perennial powerhouse with an astonishing streak of 12 straight playoff appearances, face off against their new counterpart, the Brooklyn Trolleys. This unprecedented matchup sparks curiosity: can two teams born from a single franchise both achieve greatness?
The Path to the Current Showdown
After a controversial offseason that saw the Dodgers bolster their roster with elite talent, the MLB landscape has been shaken. The Dodgers, after securing the 2024 World Series title against the New York Yankees, have raised eyebrows and concerns alike. With estimates placing their luxury tax payroll at a staggering $374.1 million, questions arise: have the Dodgers created an unassailable monopoly?
In response to the Dodgers' dominance, a fictional opportunity emerged—split the franchise in half, allowing both teams to compete independently. Thus, the Trolleys were born, a team stocked with top-tier players, ready to contend against their Los Angeles predecessors.
The Anticipated Matchup
As the tension builds, both teams' lineups reflect a mix of seasoned talent and budding stars:
Los Angeles Dodgers:
- Shohei Ohtani (DH)
- Tommy Edman (3B)
- Will Smith (C)
- Teoscar Hernandez (RF)
- Michael Conforto (LF)
- Andy Pages (CF)
- Dalton Rushing (1B)
- Chris Taylor (SS)
- Alex Freeland (2B)
Brooklyn Trolleys:
- Mookie Betts (RF)
- Freddie Freeman (1B)
- Max Muncy (3B)
- Hyeseong Kim (2B)
- Miguel Rojas (SS)
- James Outman (CF)
- Austin Barnes (C)
- Josue De Paula (LF)
- Austin Gauthier (DH)
Pitching Showdown
The Dodgers counter with a star-studded rotation, featuring Yoshinobu Yamamoto, Tyler Glasnow, and Shohei Ohtani. The Trolleys, however, boast Roki Sasaki, Blake Snell, and the legendary Clayton Kershaw. Both teams' bullpens are equally formidable, creating what many call a pitcher's dream.
Strategy and Predictions
With two competitive rosters, the scenario hints at fierce rivalry and brilliant strategic play. Although on paper the Dodgers had a slight edge, the Trolleys could defy expectations with their momentum and raw talent.
Considering detailed match simulations, both teams would likely land postseason berths, yet predictions shine a light on what is surely an uncertain journey towards the World Series. With a projected win range hovering around 78-84 wins, the stakes are high for both clubs.
The storied history of baseball echoes through Ebbets Field as players take their positions and fans hold their breath. The Dodgers have climbed back to the peak of achievement, yet the birth of the Trolleys may reshape the future of baseball as we know it. Can two Dodgers teams rule baseball or will one eclipse the other?
Conclusion
As this fantasy unfolds, the legacy of baseball evolves, mirroring the passion and competition that define the sport. The Dodgers and Trolleys have the potential to ignite a new chapter in MLB history, reminding everyone that in this game, anything is possible.
Final Thoughts
In this wild landscape of split franchises and new potentials, one truth remains: baseball is as unpredictable as it is thrilling. The Dodgers may have built an empire, but the Trolleys are out to carve their own name in history.