Bill Barnwell: The greatest rookie seasons in NFL history, and why we might be watching No. 1

The Commanders quarterback had 31 touchdowns in the regular season and has already won two playoff games. How does he stack up vs. the best ever?

Jayden Daniels is one game away from going where no rookie quarterback has gone before. With a Commanders win over the Eagles on Sunday in the NFC Championship Game, he would become the first rookie passer in league history to lead his team to a Super Bowl. Beating Philadelphia for the second time in six weeks and advancing to the title game would be the latest in a series of stunning accomplishments. It would also raise a question I'm not sure even the most optimistic of Washington fans would have expected to ask after the 2024 season:Is Daniels having the best rookie season in NFL history?While his season isn't yet complete, it's possible to compare the No. 2 pick to other great rookies from the past, many of whom were already on vacation by the time the NFL got down to the final four teams in the playoff bracket. There's a significant element of subjectivity in deciding where he stands versus his peers from the past, but there are also a few objective measures of performance to use to gauge where he lands.Let's break all that down. I'll compare Daniels to great rookies from previous years, contextualize what has made this season so impressive and try to somehow decide where he ranks among the tens of thousands of other rookies in NFL history. All of that has to start somewhere, and I'll begin by comparing him to the best rookie quarterbacks ever.

What to Read Next

Baker Mayfield's Heroic Drive Seals Tampa Bay Buccaneers' Thrilling Victory Over Houston Texans
NFL

Baker Mayfield's Heroic Drive Seals Tampa Bay Buccaneers' Thrilling Victory Over Houston Texans

Baker Mayfield leads the Tampa Bay Buccaneers to a dramatic 20-19 victory over the Houston Texans with a clutch game-winning drive.

NFL Week 2 Highlights: Fan-Voted 'Himmy' Award Showcases Top Performances
NFL

NFL Week 2 Highlights: Fan-Voted 'Himmy' Award Showcases Top Performances

Discover the standout players of NFL Week 2 as fans vote for the 'Himmy' Award, highlighting exceptional performances from Brandon Aubrey, Jared Goff, and more.

NFL Week 2: Unforgettable Moments and Bold Statements That Shaped the Game
NFL

NFL Week 2: Unforgettable Moments and Bold Statements That Shaped the Game

Dive into the thrilling outcomes and candid reactions from NFL Week 2, featuring key games and insightful player quotes.

Top Fantasy Football Pickups to Replace Joe Burrow and Boost Your Roster in Week 3
NFL

Top Fantasy Football Pickups to Replace Joe Burrow and Boost Your Roster in Week 3

Discover the best available quarterbacks and other key players to replace Joe Burrow and enhance your fantasy football roster for Week 3 of the NFL season.

NFL Week 3 Betting Insights: Key Matchups and Predictions
NFL

NFL Week 3 Betting Insights: Key Matchups and Predictions

Explore the top NFL Week 3 betting picks, including insights on the Colts, Commanders, and Bears, and key matchups to watch.

Tucker Kraft's Stellar Performance Signals a Promising NFL Season
NFL

Tucker Kraft's Stellar Performance Signals a Promising NFL Season

Tucker Kraft's impressive 124-yard game for the Green Bay Packers hints at a breakout NFL season, showcasing his potential as a top tight end.

Steelers Defense Struggles Continue: Can Pittsburgh Turn the Tide in the NFL Season?
NFL

Steelers Defense Struggles Continue: Can Pittsburgh Turn the Tide in the NFL Season?

The Pittsburgh Steelers' defense faces ongoing challenges as they struggle to contain opponents, raising questions about their ability to rebound in the 2025 NFL season.

Broncos' Fourth-Quarter Collapse Leads to Heartbreaking Loss Against Colts
NFL

Broncos' Fourth-Quarter Collapse Leads to Heartbreaking Loss Against Colts

The Denver Broncos' fourth-quarter errors led to a stunning 29-28 loss to the Indianapolis Colts, highlighting critical mistakes and missed opportunities.

C.J. Stroud's Journey: Balancing Faith, Fame, and Football in the NFL
NFL

C.J. Stroud's Journey: Balancing Faith, Fame, and Football in the NFL

Houston Texans quarterback C.J. Stroud shares his journey of balancing faith, fame, and football, focusing on personal growth and team success.

Geno Smith's New Era: Leading the Las Vegas Raiders to Glory
NFL

Geno Smith's New Era: Leading the Las Vegas Raiders to Glory

Geno Smith finds a new home with the Las Vegas Raiders, aiming to lead the team to success under the guidance of coach Pete Carroll.

NFL Week 2 Thrillers: Cowboys, Colts, and Bengals Stage Epic Comebacks
NFL

NFL Week 2 Thrillers: Cowboys, Colts, and Bengals Stage Epic Comebacks

Week 2 of the NFL season saw dramatic comebacks from the Cowboys, Colts, and Bengals. Dive into the thrilling finishes and what lies ahead for these teams.

Baker Mayfield Aims for Greater Success in Year 3 with the Buccaneers
NFL

Baker Mayfield Aims for Greater Success in Year 3 with the Buccaneers

Baker Mayfield seeks to build on his career-best season with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, aiming for more wins and team success in Year 3.

Jim Harbaugh vs. Pete Carroll: A Rivalry Rekindled on Monday Night Football
NFL

Jim Harbaugh vs. Pete Carroll: A Rivalry Rekindled on Monday Night Football

Explore the intense, nearly two-decade-long rivalry between Jim Harbaugh and Pete Carroll as they face off again in the NFL.

Drake Maye's Stellar Performance Leads Patriots to Victory Over Dolphins
NFL

Drake Maye's Stellar Performance Leads Patriots to Victory Over Dolphins

Drake Maye showcased significant improvement as he led the New England Patriots to a thrilling 33-27 victory over the Miami Dolphins in NFL Week 2.

Sam Darnold Shines as Seattle Seahawks Dominate Pittsburgh Steelers in Week 2 Showdown
NFL

Sam Darnold Shines as Seattle Seahawks Dominate Pittsburgh Steelers in Week 2 Showdown

Sam Darnold led the Seattle Seahawks to a commanding 31-17 victory over the Pittsburgh Steelers, showcasing his versatility and poise in a game-changing performance.

Load More

We use essential cookies to make our site work. With your consent, we may also use non-essential cookies to improve user experience and analyze website traffic. By clicking "Accept," you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy.