College Football Coaches' First-Year Reviews: Hits, Misses, and What's Next

A look at the first-year performances of college football coaches in 2024, including their hires, records, and grades.

The 2024 college football season saw a number of new coaches take the reins at various programs. Some made an immediate impact, while others struggled to find their footing. Here's a look at how the first-year coaches fared and what's next for them.

UCLA Bruins

DeShaun Foster took over as head coach at UCLA and led the Bruins to a 5-7 record. Foster was a late-cycle promotion, but he took over the role amid some skepticism about his readiness. He drew a better mark from me than other hiring evaluators, but the concern increased after his Big Ten media day freeze-up, and after the team started 1-5 while playing a very tough schedule. But Foster never lost the locker room and the Bruins put together a nice midseason win streak against Rutgers, Nebraska, and Iowa, claiming the first two on the road. Other than the Big Ten opener against Indiana, UCLA competed, even in its losses, and saw linebacker Carson Schwesinger emerge into a national star. Foster's offseason staff overhaul suggests he will have more of an imprint on the program this coming season. He also should have a greater comfort level overall.

Boston College Eagles

Bill O'Brien was hired as the head coach at Boston College and led the Eagles to a 7-6 record. O'Brien understands how to run a team, which came across in his first season at Boston College, despite some expected inconsistency in performance. He guided the Eagles to a 4-1 start that included wins against Florida State and Michigan State, with the lone blemish being a six-point loss at Missouri. Boston College then endured a three-game losing streak that culminated with a quarterback change from Thomas Castellanos to Grayson James. O'Brien made a tough call there but seemingly the right one, as James helped BC to wins over Syracuse, North Carolina, and Pitt. Despite a very late coaching change, the Eagles made their second straight bowl appearance in O'Brien's first season.

Michigan Wolverines

Sherrone Moore was hired as the head coach at Michigan and led the Wolverines to an 8-5 record. Michigan wasn't truly built to return to the College Football Playoff after winning the national title in 2023, especially without adding a transfer quarterback to replace J.J. McCarthy. But the team's offensive regression -- Michigan slipped to 130th nationally in passing, ahead of only the three service academies -- and some of Moore's in-game decisions stirred doubt about the first-year coach. Michigan split its first 10 games and went 0-3 on the road. Moore delivered down the stretch, though, as Michigan clobbered Northwestern and then stunned Ohio State in Columbus as a three-touchdown underdog. The Wolverines beat the Buckeyes for the fourth straight year and second under Moore, who served as acting head coach for the 2023 victory. Moore then guided a vastly undermanned Wolverines team over Alabama in the ReliaQuest Bowl, regaining the momentum lost during the first two-plus months of the season.

What to Read Next

Top 10 Under-the-Radar Prospects for the 2026 NFL Draft: Who Could Rise Quickly?
NCAAF

Top 10 Under-the-Radar Prospects for the 2026 NFL Draft: Who Could Rise Quickly?

Discover the top 10 under-the-radar prospects for the 2026 NFL Draft as identified by NFL scouts. These players could rise quickly in the draft rankings.

2025-2026 NCAAF Future Power Rankings: Top 68 Teams Analyzed
NCAAF

2025-2026 NCAAF Future Power Rankings: Top 68 Teams Analyzed

Comprehensive analysis of the top 68 NCAAF teams for the 2025 and 2026 seasons, focusing on rosters, recruiting, and transfer portal impacts.

USC's Creative Recruitment Strategy: Trolling Oregon with 'Anchorman' Commitment Alert
NCAAF

USC's Creative Recruitment Strategy: Trolling Oregon with 'Anchorman' Commitment Alert

USC Trojans creatively announce the commitment of four-star tight end Mark Bowman by trolling Oregon Ducks' head coach Dan Lanning with a unique 'Anchorman' twist.

Heisman Trophy 2025: Analyzing the Odds for Jeremiah Smith and Ryan Williams
NCAAF

Heisman Trophy 2025: Analyzing the Odds for Jeremiah Smith and Ryan Williams

Dive into the Heisman Trophy prospects of Jeremiah Smith and Ryan Williams, analyzing their odds, strengths, and potential to win the prestigious award in the 2025 NCAAF season.

Revising NCAA Football: The Stars Who Could Have Graced the Covers During the 11-Year Hiatus
NCAAF

Revising NCAA Football: The Stars Who Could Have Graced the Covers During the 11-Year Hiatus

Explore the hypothetical stars who could have graced the covers of NCAA Football during its 11-year hiatus, revisiting the legends and moments that defined college football.

2025 NCAAF Quarterback Rankings: A Comprehensive Tier Analysis
NCAAF

2025 NCAAF Quarterback Rankings: A Comprehensive Tier Analysis

Explore the detailed tier rankings of all 136 FBS quarterbacks for the 2025 NCAAF season, featuring top talents and emerging stars.

Curt Cignetti's Indiana Hoosiers: Building on a Stellar First Year
NCAAF

Curt Cignetti's Indiana Hoosiers: Building on a Stellar First Year

After a record-breaking first year, Curt Cignetti and the Indiana Hoosiers aim to elevate their game in the upcoming NCAAF season.

Top 100 NCAAF Transfer Portal Players: Key Moves and Impact for 2025 Season
NCAAF

Top 100 NCAAF Transfer Portal Players: Key Moves and Impact for 2025 Season

Explore the definitive rankings of the top 100 players in the NCAAF Transfer Portal for the 2025 season, highlighting key moves and their potential impact.

The Rising Era of College Football General Managers
NCAAF

The Rising Era of College Football General Managers

The rise of GMs in college football, changing the game with NFL influence and new challenges.

2026 NCAAF Recruiting Class: Powerhouses and Rising Stars
NCAAF

2026 NCAAF Recruiting Class: Powerhouses and Rising Stars

The 2026 NCAAF recruiting class is heating up. See which teams are leading and who the top prospects are.

Elbert Hill Commits to USC, Boosting Trojans' 2026 Recruiting Class
NCAAF

Elbert Hill Commits to USC, Boosting Trojans' 2026 Recruiting Class

Five-star cornerback Elbert Hill commits to USC, strengthening their 2026 class.

Impact of Players' Decisions on College Football Playoff
NCAAF

Impact of Players' Decisions on College Football Playoff

Analysis of players who stayed and their impact on teams' playoff chances.

Belichick's Unwavering Focus Amidst Relationship Scrutiny
NCAAF

Belichick's Unwavering Focus Amidst Relationship Scrutiny

Bill Belichick's girlfriend controversy in college football, but his focus remains unbroken.

Replacing NFL Draft Picks in College Football: The Next Wave of Stars
NCAAF

Replacing NFL Draft Picks in College Football: The Next Wave of Stars

Explore who could replace NFL draft picks in college football and their potential.

2025 NCAAF Betting Insights: Teams to Watch and Their Prospects
NCAAF

2025 NCAAF Betting Insights: Teams to Watch and Their Prospects

Analysis of key college football teams after spring practices and their betting odds.

Load More

We use essential cookies to make our site work. With your consent, we may also use non-essential cookies to improve user experience and analyze website traffic. By clicking "Accept," you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy.