Shedeur Sanders: Can the Browns' Fifth-Round Pick Defy Odds to Become Starting QB?

Shedeur Sanders, a fifth-round pick, aims to overcome historic odds and become the Cleveland Browns' starting quarterback. Can he rise to the challenge?

Shedeur Sanders' Journey to the NFL

Three days after his unexpected fall to the fifth round in the 2025 NFL draft, Cleveland Browns quarterback Shedeur Sanders was back to work in his new NFL home. Sanders, who had made his way from Canton, Texas, where he watched the draft, to Cleveland, stood on a hill wearing a black T-shirt, gray shorts, and a pair of Nike Air DT Max '96s. In a clip posted to X, Sanders shuffled sideways up the incline, as if defending a ball handler in a basketball game, before pivoting and sprinting toward the top of the hill.

Days later, on a blue, indoor practice field located in a west Cleveland suburb, Sanders, in a white, long-sleeve shirt and black shorts, called for an under-center handoff with a commanding cadence and rolled to his left before launching passes to a group of volunteer pass catchers as music blasted throughout the training facility.

The Road Ahead for Sanders

These individual workouts -- away from the crowds and cameras -- were the preamble to Sanders' next professional milestone, set to take place the following week: his first NFL practice. On Friday, the first steppingstone of Sanders' pro career will unfold when the Browns hold a three-day rookie minicamp. The former Colorado star will be joined by his fellow draftmates and a host of undrafted rookies and tryout players aiming to begin -- and in some instances maintain -- their careers with a strong showing.

Sanders will arrive at the camp with an outsized spotlight for a fifth-round pick. His celebrity upbringing as the son of Pro Football Hall of Famer Deion Sanders, transformative success at two college football programs, and then a surprising fall from potential top pick to Day 3 selection have only added to the intrigue surrounding him.

Challenges and Opportunities

In Cleveland, a franchise that hasn't had a Pro Bowl quarterback since Derek Anderson in 2007, Sanders is expected to receive an opportunity to compete for the starting job. But he will have to overcome a number of challenges to emerge as QB1 this fall -- most notably a crowded quarterbacks room, a tendency to take ill-advised sacks, and a draft slot that has a poor track record of producing successful quarterbacks, let alone Week 1 starters.

Sanders, though, is embracing the road ahead. "I'm a Sanders," he said after he was selected 144th overall in the draft, "so it's always going to be expectations regardless of what pick I am."

Historical Context

Shedeur Sanders is attempting a feat only Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott has accomplished in the past 15 years -- parlaying a Day 3 draft slot into becoming a franchise's Week 1 starter as a rookie. He's also trying to do something only four men have done since 1967: doing it as a fifth-round or later selection. But although history isn't on Sanders' side, his unique situation in Cleveland -- with a lack of clarity within the Browns' QB room -- and his talent relative to his draft slot could set the stage for him to buck the trend.

Conclusion

When Sanders takes the field at the Browns' practice facility for the first time Friday, he won't do so as the face of the franchise but as a late-round pick whose draft status signals he'll have to thoroughly outplay his competition to emerge as a starter or top backup in the coming months. Browns coach Kevin Stefanski said that practice reps might not be spread out equally among the quarterbacks but that he'll divide them up in a way that is "fair to each player and fair to the team."

What to Read Next

Aaron Rodgers' Transition to the Steelers: A Clash of Styles and Strategies
NFL

Aaron Rodgers' Transition to the Steelers: A Clash of Styles and Strategies

Aaron Rodgers joins the Pittsburgh Steelers, but his playing style may not align with the team's offensive strategies under Mike Tomlin and Arthur Smith.

Top NFL Teams Poised for a Worst-to-First Turnaround in the 2025 Season
NFL

Top NFL Teams Poised for a Worst-to-First Turnaround in the 2025 Season

Explore the top NFL teams likely to make a worst-to-first turnaround in the 2025 season, based on Football Power Index and key performance indicators.

NFL Players in Olympic Flag Football: A Game-Changer or a Risk to the Sport's Future?
NFL

NFL Players in Olympic Flag Football: A Game-Changer or a Risk to the Sport's Future?

Exploring the implications of NFL players participating in flag football at the 2028 LA Olympics and its impact on the sport's future.

Puka Nacua Steps Up as Rams' New Leader in the Wake of Cooper Kupp's Departure
NFL

Puka Nacua Steps Up as Rams' New Leader in the Wake of Cooper Kupp's Departure

Explore how Puka Nacua is embracing a leadership role with the Los Angeles Rams following Cooper Kupp's move to the Seattle Seahawks, and the impact of Davante Adams' arrival.

Romeo Doubs' Crucial Year: Proving His Worth in the 2025 NFL Season
NFL

Romeo Doubs' Crucial Year: Proving His Worth in the 2025 NFL Season

Romeo Doubs faces a pivotal year with the Green Bay Packers, aiming to overcome past challenges and secure his future in the NFL.

Steelers Confidently Navigate OTAs Without Aaron Rodgers: A Strategic Approach to 2025 NFL Season
NFL

Steelers Confidently Navigate OTAs Without Aaron Rodgers: A Strategic Approach to 2025 NFL Season

The Pittsburgh Steelers are progressing through OTAs without Aaron Rodgers, focusing on team chemistry and strategic development for the 2025 NFL season.

Bo Nix's Journey: From Rookie Sensation to Broncos' Franchise Leader
NFL

Bo Nix's Journey: From Rookie Sensation to Broncos' Franchise Leader

Denver Broncos' Bo Nix reflects on his successful rookie season, his preparation for Year 2, and his aspirations to become the franchise's long-term leader.

Buccaneers' Annual 'Cut and Color Funds the Cure' Event Raises Over $760,000 for Pediatric Cancer Research
NFL

Buccaneers' Annual 'Cut and Color Funds the Cure' Event Raises Over $760,000 for Pediatric Cancer Research

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers hosted their 11th annual 'Cut and Color Funds the Cure' event, raising significant funds for the National Pediatric Cancer Foundation.

Top 20 NFL Rookies to Watch in the 2025 Fantasy Football Season
NFL

Top 20 NFL Rookies to Watch in the 2025 Fantasy Football Season

Discover the top 20 NFL rookies to target in your 2025 fantasy football drafts, complete with expert analysis and draft round recommendations.

How 'Turk' Wharton's Championship Pedigree Can Revitalize the Panthers' Defense
NFL

How 'Turk' Wharton's Championship Pedigree Can Revitalize the Panthers' Defense

Discover how Tershawn 'Turk' Wharton's championship experience and work ethic are set to transform the Carolina Panthers' defense under coordinator Ejiro Evero.

Top NFL Signings and Trades: Which Players Will Thrive in Their New Teams?
NFL

Top NFL Signings and Trades: Which Players Will Thrive in Their New Teams?

Explore the top NFL signings and trades of the 2025 season, analyzing which players will benefit most from their new teams and how they can impact the league.

Liam Coen: From UMass Record Holder to Jaguars Head Coach - A Journey of Football Mastery
NFL

Liam Coen: From UMass Record Holder to Jaguars Head Coach - A Journey of Football Mastery

Explore Liam Coen's remarkable journey from a UMass record holder to the Jacksonville Jaguars' head coach, detailing his influences and coaching philosophy.

Bijan Robinson and Raheem Morris: Building Bonds Beyond the Gridiron
NFL

Bijan Robinson and Raheem Morris: Building Bonds Beyond the Gridiron

Discover how Bijan Robinson and Raheem Morris strengthened their bond at a boxing match, enhancing their on-field chemistry and leadership.

Tanner Engstrand Aims to Stabilize Jets' Offensive Coordination Amidst Historical Volatility
NFL

Tanner Engstrand Aims to Stabilize Jets' Offensive Coordination Amidst Historical Volatility

Tanner Engstrand steps into the challenging role of offensive coordinator for the New York Jets, aiming to break the cycle of instability that has plagued the position.

From Fan to Pro: Denzel Burke's Journey to the Arizona Cardinals
NFL

From Fan to Pro: Denzel Burke's Journey to the Arizona Cardinals

Discover how Denzel Burke transitioned from a Cardinals fan to a fifth-round pick, fulfilling his dream of playing for his hometown team in the NFL.

Load More

We use essential cookies to make our site work. With your consent, we may also use non-essential cookies to improve user experience and analyze website traffic. By clicking "Accept," you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy.