USWNT Goalkeeper Crisis: Who Will Step Up as the New No. 1?

The Search for a New USWNT Goalkeeping Star

For the first time in decades, the USWNT finds itself without a clear-cut starting goalkeeper. The retirement of Alyssa Naeher, following her stellar career that included two World Cup wins and an Olympic gold medal, has left a void that several promising but inexperienced goalkeepers are now battling to fill.

The Contenders

Phallon Tullis-Joyce (Manchester United) made a strong case in her debut against Brazil, earning a clean sheet with six saves. "The first whistle was my toughest test," admitted the 28-year-old, highlighting the nerves that come with such high-stakes opportunities.

Other candidates include:

Jane Campbell (Houston Dash): Previously considered the frontrunner
Mandy McGlynn (Utah Royals): Showed promise despite recent struggles
Casey Murphy (North Carolina Courage): The most experienced option with 20 caps

Challenges Ahead

Head coach Emma Hayes faces tough decisions:

Lack of big-game experience: Current pool has combined for just 12 caps
Stylistic adjustments: Hayes demands goalkeepers comfortable with possession
Performance pressure: "This is a performance-related business," Hayes emphasized

Historical Context

The USWNT has navigated goalkeeper transitions before:

Hope Solo succeeded Briana Scurry in 2008
Naeher replaced Solo amid skepticism in 2019

However, unlike previous transitions where successors had tournament experience, the current candidates have minimal exposure to major competitions.

The Road to 2027

Hayes aims to identify her No. 1 by July, giving the chosen goalkeeper two years to prepare for the next World Cup. The evaluation process includes upcoming friendlies against China, Ireland, and Canada.

"They have to take their chances when they get them," Hayes stated, underscoring the competitive nature of the position.

Statistical Standouts

Murphy leads NWSL in post-shot expected goals metrics
Tullis-Joyce dominates similar stats in England's WSL
McGlynn was last season's top American in shot-stopping

With such closely matched competitors, the goalkeeper battle promises to be one of the most intriguing roster decisions facing the USWNT in recent memory.