Hidden Gems of the 2025 NFL Draft: Underrated Prospects Who Dominate on Tape

Rising Stars: The Best Tape You Haven’t Seen Yet

The 2025 NFL Draft hype surrounds household names like Cam Ward, Travis Hunter, and Abdul Carter—but the real draft-day steals lurk beneath the marquee headlines. These are the players who won’t dominate Mel Kiper’s mock drafts but dominate on film. Here’s a position-by-position breakdown of under-the-radar prospects with NFL-ready tape.

Quarterback: Tyler Shough, Louisville

• Why He Stands Out: A 25-year-old with a cannon arm and underrated mobility, Shough thrived against ACC defenses despite a history of injuries. His touch on deep throws (see this NFL-caliber play-action TD) and composure under pressure evoke Jared Goff’s early career.
• Red Flags: Age and durability concerns could push him to Day 2, but his film suggests starter potential at a discount.

Running Back: Devin Neal, Kansas

• Why He Stands Out: A workhorse (760 carries, 5.7 YPC) with elite vision, pass-catching chops, and blitz pickup skills. Think Zack Moss with better agility.
• Limitation: Lacks breakaway speed (4.58 40-yard dash), but his consistency makes him a Day 3 steal for run-heavy schemes.

Wide Receiver: Jack Bech, TCU

• Why He Stands Out: A YAC monster with Cooper Kupp-esque route transitions. His highlight reel showcases rare agility for a 215-pound former TE.
• Best Fit: Shanahan-style offenses needing a slot/backfield hybrid. Watch for the Texans at No. 58.

Defensive Sleeper: Tyleik Williams, Ohio State

• Why He Stands Out: At 330 lbs, he’s a run-stuffing force with Alim McNeill’s upside. His tape vs. Iowa proves he’s a first-round talent trapped in a mid-round frame.
• Question Mark: Can he develop as a pass rusher?

The ‘Trust the Tape’ Philosophy

These prospects share one trait: production over pedigree. Whether it’s LSU OT Will Campbell (3-year SEC starter with 33" arms) or Texas S Andrew Mukuba (a 4.4-speed playmaker in a nickel’s body), their film demands attention—even if combine numbers don’t.

For more draft insights, follow @BenjaminSolak.