Fantasy Hockey Goaltending Deep Dive: 2025 Season Review & Future Projections

Comprehensive analysis of NHL goalie performance in fantasy hockey with expert predictions for the 2025-26 season, including breakout candidates and strategy tips.

The Changing Landscape of Fantasy Goaltending

Over the past decade, we've witnessed a dramatic shift in fantasy hockey goaltending value. Where once netminders dominated the upper echelons of fantasy rankings, recent seasons have seen a significant decline in their overall impact - but signs point to a potential resurgence.

Historical Perspective:

  • 2014-15 Season: 7 of top 10 fantasy players were goalies
  • 2017-18 Season: 6 of top 10 were netminders
  • 2019-20 Season: Major decline with only 2 top-10 goalies
  • 2023-24 Season: Rock bottom with zero goalies in top 10

Current Season Trends

The 2024-25 campaign represents a slight rebound for fantasy goalies:

  • A goaltender has reclaimed the #1 overall fantasy spot
  • Two netminders projected to finish top-10 (matching 2019-20 numbers)
  • Nine goalies likely to land in top 100 fantasy players

Key Factors Influencing Performance:

  1. Timeshares: Increased crease splitting reduces individual value
  2. Age Fluctuations: Top-10 goalie age dropped to 27.6 (2022-23) before rebounding to 30.3
  3. Emerging Talent: New generation of young goalies developing

Team-by-Team Fantasy Outlook

Top Contenders:

  • Winnipeg Jets: Connor Hellebuyck (#1 fantasy goalie) continues to dominate
  • Tampa Bay Lightning: Andrei Vasilevskiy remains elite (#2 ranked)
  • Minnesota Wild: Filip Gustavsson emerging as top-3 option

Rising Stars:

  • Calgary Flames: Dustin Wolf (#10 among goalies) shows great promise
  • Carolina Hurricanes: Pyotr Kochetkov ready for breakout season
  • Montreal Canadiens: Sam Montembeault positioned for major improvement

Buy-Low Candidates:

  • New York Rangers: Igor Shesterkin likely to rebound after "down" year
  • New Jersey Devils: Jacob Markstrom with top-10 potential if healthy
  • Los Angeles Kings: Darcy Kuemper proving age is just a number

Future Projections for 2025-26

We're likely seeing the beginning of a goaltending renaissance:

  • Current sub-30 goalies will mature with more experience
  • Several top prospects (Yaroslav Askarov, Jesper Wallstedt) near NHL-ready
  • Improved defensive systems across league could boost goalie stats

Draft Strategy Recommendations:

  1. Early Rounds: Target proven workhorses (Hellebuyck, Vasilevskiy)
  2. Mid Rounds: Take shots on young talent (Wolf, Kochetkov)
  3. Late Rounds: Consider high-upside backups on good teams

Pro Tip: Monitor playoff performances as they may significantly alter 2025-26 draft stocks for many goalies.

What to Read Next

NHL Unveils 2025-26 Season Schedule: The Final 82-Game Campaign Before Expansion
NHL

NHL Unveils 2025-26 Season Schedule: The Final 82-Game Campaign Before Expansion

The NHL has released its full 2025-26 schedule, marking the last 82-game season before the new CBA increases it to 84 games. Key highlights include the Olympics break and Alex Ovechkin's milestone chase.

Kaapo Kakko Secures Three-Year Deal with Seattle Kraken: A Game-Changer for the Team
NHL

Kaapo Kakko Secures Three-Year Deal with Seattle Kraken: A Game-Changer for the Team

Kaapo Kakko signs a three-year contract with the Seattle Kraken, promising to elevate the team's performance with his exceptional skills.

Yegor Chinakhov Seeks New NHL Chapter: Trade Request Amidst Columbus Blue Jackets Tensions
NHL

Yegor Chinakhov Seeks New NHL Chapter: Trade Request Amidst Columbus Blue Jackets Tensions

Yegor Chinakhov, the 21st pick in the 2020 NHL draft, has requested a trade from the Columbus Blue Jackets following a season of misunderstandings with the coach.

Gabriel Vilardi's $45 Million Extension: A Game-Changer for the Winnipeg Jets
NHL

Gabriel Vilardi's $45 Million Extension: A Game-Changer for the Winnipeg Jets

The Winnipeg Jets secure forward Gabriel Vilardi with a six-year, $45 million extension, bolstering their roster for future NHL seasons.

Lukas Dostal Secures Long-Term Future with Anaheim Ducks in Blockbuster $32.5M Deal
NHL

Lukas Dostal Secures Long-Term Future with Anaheim Ducks in Blockbuster $32.5M Deal

The Anaheim Ducks have locked in goaltender Lukas Dostal with a five-year, $32.5 million contract extension, signaling their commitment to his role as their No. 1 netminder.

Jaroslav Halak Bids Farewell: A Storied NHL Career Concludes After 17 Seasons
NHL

Jaroslav Halak Bids Farewell: A Storied NHL Career Concludes After 17 Seasons

Jaroslav Halak, renowned NHL goaltender, retires after a remarkable 17-season career, leaving behind a legacy of 295 wins and numerous accolades.

NHL 2025-26 Season Preview: Power Rankings and Summer Storylines for All 32 Teams
NHL

NHL 2025-26 Season Preview: Power Rankings and Summer Storylines for All 32 Teams

Explore the latest NHL Power Rankings and summer storylines for all 32 teams as we gear up for the 2025-26 season. Get insights on key moves, player updates, and Stanley Cup odds.

Top NHL Free Agents Still Available: Impact Players Teams Should Consider
NHL

Top NHL Free Agents Still Available: Impact Players Teams Should Consider

Explore the top remaining NHL free agents and their potential impact on teams as the free agency period continues.

Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl Join Beer League Game: A Night to Remember
NHL

Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl Join Beer League Game: A Night to Remember

NHL stars Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl surprised fans by joining a beer league game in Ontario, offering a unique and memorable experience for local players.

Gavin McKenna's Move to Penn State: A Game-Changer for NHL Prospects
NHL

Gavin McKenna's Move to Penn State: A Game-Changer for NHL Prospects

Gavin McKenna's decision to join Penn State reshapes the NHL prospect landscape, highlighting the evolving paths for young hockey stars.

2025-26 NHL Season Schedule Unveiled: Bruins, Penguins, Maple Leafs Lead Creative Reveals
NHL

2025-26 NHL Season Schedule Unveiled: Bruins, Penguins, Maple Leafs Lead Creative Reveals

The 2025-26 NHL season schedule has been released, with teams like the Bruins, Penguins, and Maple Leafs showcasing their creativity in unique reveals.

NHL's New CBA: Key Changes from 84-Game Season to Emergency Goaltender Rules
NHL

NHL's New CBA: Key Changes from 84-Game Season to Emergency Goaltender Rules

Explore the NHL's new CBA changes, including an 84-game season, emergency goaltender rules, and updated LTIR and playoff cap counting regulations.

NHL Highlights and Trivia: SportsCenter's 50-in-50 Week 3 Quiz
NHL

NHL Highlights and Trivia: SportsCenter's 50-in-50 Week 3 Quiz

Join SportsCenter's 50-in-50 Week 3 quiz featuring NHL highlights and trivia. Test your knowledge on hockey and other major sports events.

NHL Offseason Overhaul: Teams That Transformed Their Rosters for 2025-26
NHL

NHL Offseason Overhaul: Teams That Transformed Their Rosters for 2025-26

Explore how NHL teams reshaped their rosters this offseason, with key additions and losses that could define the 2025-26 season.

2025-26 NHL Fantasy Hockey Rankings: Top Players to Watch and Draft Strategies
NHL

2025-26 NHL Fantasy Hockey Rankings: Top Players to Watch and Draft Strategies

Get ahead in your 2025-26 NHL fantasy hockey league with expert rankings, top player insights, and draft strategies to dominate your season.

Load More

We use essential cookies to make our site work. With your consent, we may also use non-essential cookies to improve user experience and analyze website traffic. By clicking "Accept," you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy.