NBA MVP Showdown: Jokic vs. SGA – Who Deserves the Crown in 2025?

The MVP Battle: Jokic’s Brilliance vs. SGA’s Ascendance

Nikola Jokic (Denver Nuggets) and Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (Oklahoma City Thunder) have dominated the 2024-25 MVP conversation with historic campaigns:

• SGA’s Case:

  • Leads NBA in scoring (32.1 PPG) and plus/minus (+911)
  • Thunder first to 60 wins (+13.5-game lead in West)
  • Top-3 in steals (2.1 SPG) while shooting 54% from the field

• Jokic’s Argument:

  • Near triple-double averages (26.3 PPG, 12.1 RPG, 9.4 APG)
  • NBA-best 68.3% true shooting among high-usage players
  • Nuggets +14.2 net rating with him on court (98th percentile)

Insider Perspectives:

• Tim MacMahon: "SGA’s two-way dominance for the West’s top team edges Jokic’s brilliance."
• Chris Herring: "Jokic’s impact metrics are otherworldly, but SGA’s narrative is irresistible."

Defensive Player of the Year: The Wemby Void

With Victor Wembanyama injured, the DPOY race features dark horses:

Wild Card: Jaren Jackson Jr. (MEM) making late push with 2.6 BPG in March.

Most Improved Player: Superstar Launchpad

Cade Cunningham (DET) leads the conversation:

• From 22.7/4.3/7.5 to 26.1/5.8/9.2
• Pistons’ first playoff berth since 2019
• Controversy: Should former high picks qualify?

Dark Horses:

• Amen Thompson (HOU): 14.3 PPG → 19.7 PPG as full-time starter
• Tyler Herro (MIA): Career-high 24.6 PPG as Butler’s co-star

Sixth Man of the Year: Role Player Royalty

Top Contenders:

1. Payton Pritchard (BOS): 12.7 PPG, 44% 3PT off bench
2. Malik Beasley (DET): 13.9 PPG, elite spacing for Cade
3. Naz Reid (MIN): 15.4 PPG, 7.2 RPG in 24 MPG

Trend Watch: Only 2 Sixth Man winners became All-Stars since 2012.

The 65-Game Rule Debate

Proposed Reforms:

• 🟢 Remove minutes requirement for All-Defense teams
• 🔴 Keep for MVP but adjust for legit injuries
• Stat: 8 All-NBA candidates fell short of 65 games last season

Insider Consensus: 4/5 analysts favor modifications

Playoff Implications

• Thunder clinched #1 seed with SGA’s MVP case
• Nuggets fighting for top-3 seed to bolster Jokic’s argument
• Cavaliers’ Mobley making late DPOY push for East’s #2 seed