Top NFL Free Agency Signings of 2025: Seth Walder's 'A' Grade Picks and Hidden Gems

Seth Walder's Top NFL Free Agency Signings of 2025

Seth Walder, ESPN's analytics expert, has evaluated over 60 NFL free agent signings and trades this offseason, awarding only a select few with coveted 'A' grades. Here’s a breakdown of the top deals that stood out, along with one signing that initially missed the mark but now deserves recognition.

1. Zack Baun Re-Signs with the Eagles

• Deal: 3 years, $51 million ($34 million guaranteed)
• Why It’s an A: Baun’s transformation into an elite off-ball linebacker was one of the best development stories of 2024. His performance, including a near-Defensive Player of the Year campaign, makes this deal a steal for the Eagles.

2. Kevin Zeitler Signs with the Titans

• Deal: 1 year, $9 million
• Why It’s an A: Despite being 35, Zeitler remains one of the best pass-blocking guards in the league. His reliability and experience make him a valuable addition to Tennessee’s offensive line.

3. D.J. Reed Signs with the Lions

• Deal: 3 years, $48 million
• Why It’s an A: Reed’s consistency and underrated play at cornerback make him a perfect fit for Detroit’s secondary. His ability to limit yards per coverage snap is a major asset.

4. Dan Moore Jr. Signs with the Titans

• Deal: 4 years, $82 million ($50 million guaranteed)
• Why It’s an A: Moore’s career-high pass block win rate (93%) and run block win rate (76%) make him a key addition to Tennessee’s offensive line, providing stability for their future quarterback.

5. Davante Adams Signs with the Rams

• Deal: 2 years, $46 million ($26 million guaranteed)
• Why It’s an A: Despite being 32, Adams remains a top-tier receiver. His ability to produce in a Sean McVay offense makes this a smart move for the Rams.

The Hindsight A Grade: Ronnie Stanley Re-Signs with the Ravens

• Deal: 3 years, $60 million
• Why It’s an A: Initially graded a B+, Stanley’s re-signing is now seen as a bargain. Protecting Lamar Jackson is crucial, and Stanley’s experience and skill make him worth the investment.

Underrated Moves

• Rico Dowdle Signs with the Panthers: A one-year, $3 million deal for a running back who outperformed expectations in 2024.
• Malcolm Koonce Re-Signs with the Raiders: A one-year, $12 million deal for an edge rusher with high upside.

These signings not only strengthen their respective teams but also set the stage for an exciting 2025 NFL season.