The announcement that FIFA is considering a Super Bowl-style halftime show for the 2026 World Cup final has sparked a mix of excitement and concern among soccer fans and purists. While the idea of adding a musical spectacle to the biggest sporting event in the world is undeniably appealing, it raises important questions about the balance between entertainment and tradition in soccer.

The Super Bowl Influence

FIFA President Gianni Infantino has been inspired by the grandeur of the Super Bowl halftime show, a cultural phenomenon that attracts millions of viewers worldwide. The Super Bowl halftime is known for its star-studded performances, elaborate stage setups, and memorable moments—often unrelated to the game itself. However, the NFL's approach to halftime shows is fundamentally different from soccer's.

In the NFL, halftime can extend to 30 minutes or more, allowing for extensive production and performances. In contrast, soccer’s halftime is strictly limited to 15 minutes, as outlined in the Laws of the Game. This is not merely a tradition but a necessity for players, who are conditioned to this brief break to rest, rehydrate, and receive tactical instructions.

The Red Line: 15 Minutes

Colombia coach Nestor Lorenzo emphasized the importance of this rule after the 2024 Copa America final, where halftime was extended to 25 minutes to accommodate a performance by Shakira. Lorenzo pointed out that disrupting players’ routines can lead to physical discomfort and negatively impact performance. This serves as a reminder that while entertainment is valuable, it must not compromise the integrity of the sport.

The Perils of Over-Commercialization

Many fans and analysts worry that FIFA’s push for a more extravagant halftime show is part of a broader trend of over-commercialization in soccer. Critics argue that such changes risk alienating traditional fans, who cherish the simplicity and purity of the game. However, as my colleague Luis Miguel Echegaray notes, these halftime spectacles are not primarily aimed at die-hard fans but at casual viewers who might tune in for the entertainment.

A Proposed Compromise

If FIFA decides to proceed with a halftime show, it must adhere to the 15-minute rule. This could mean simplifying the production process, staging performances in the stands or corners of the stadium, or even using innovative solutions like suspended platforms. The key is to ensure that the show is concise and does not disrupt the flow of the game.

The Bigger Picture

Football has evolved significantly over the years, with changes in technology, tactics, and global reach. While a halftime show may seem like a minor adjustment, it reflects the ongoing tension between preserving tradition and embracing modern entertainment. As the sport continues to grow, finding a balance between these two priorities will be crucial.

In conclusion, while a Super Bowl-style halftime show could bring new dimensions to the World Cup, FIFA must prioritize the 15-minute halftime rule. After all, the essence of the World Cup lies in the game itself, and any changes should enhance, not diminish, the sporting spectacle that captivates billions worldwide.