Top 14 Underrated NFL Free Agency Signings for 2025: Unlocking Hidden Value in the Cornerback Market

The Hidden Gems of the 2025 NFL Free Agency

The 2025 NFL free agency class might not seem star-studded at first glance, but it’s a goldmine for teams with a sharp eye. While the big names are either franchised tagged or already signed, there’s a wealth of untapped talent waiting to be discovered. The competitive edge this year isn’t about who has the deepest pockets but who can identify the best value in the second, third, and fourth tiers of NFL starters.

How Teams Can Win Big on the Margins

History shows that great free agency wins often happen on the margins. Take the Philadelphia Eagles, for example. Their defense didn’t reach Super Bowl heights because of the $51 million they spent on edge rusher Bryce Huff, but rather the $3.5 million they invested in linebacker Zack Baun. This year, the key to success lies in identifying players who can thrive in the right system, even if they’re not headline-grabbing names.

Spotlight on Key Players

1. Carlton Davis III (CB, Detroit Lions)

   • Age in 2025: 28
   • Value Insight: Davis was the clear CB1 in Detroit’s man-heavy defense before his season-ending injury. While he’s had a rocky injury history, his versatility and press-man skills make him a valuable asset for teams like the Ravens, Colts, Packers, and Vikings.
   • Projected Deal: 3 years, $42 million

2. Will Fries (G, Indianapolis Colts)

   • Age in 2025: 27
   • Value Insight: Fries, a seventh-round pick, emerged as one of the best young guards in the league. He’s technically sound and excels in pass protection, making him a safer bet than flashier players like Mekhi Becton.
   • Projected Deal: 4 years, $51.5 million

3. Rico Dowdle (RB, Dallas Cowboys)

   • Age in 2025: 27
   • Value Insight: Dowdle emerged late in the 2024 season as a consistent grinder with a high success rate. He’s a perfect fit for teams like the Raiders, Broncos, and Chargers looking for a 1A back.
   • Projected Deal: 2 years, $8 million

4. Jamien Sherwood (LB, New York Jets)

   • Age in 2025: 25
   • Value Insight: Sherwood is a rangy, high-impact linebacker with coverage instincts. He’s a future Pro Bowler in the making and could thrive in a blitz-heavy scheme.
   • Projected Deal: 3 years, $22.5 million

The Deep Cuts

• Jack Sanborn (LB, Bears): A hard-nosed strongside linebacker who excels in base defense.
• Isaiah Rodgers (CB, Eagles): A rangy corner with high upside after a suspension derailed his development.
• Juwan Johnson (TE, Saints): A mismatch nightmare in play-action-heavy offenses.

Conclusion

While the 2025 free agency class lacks marquee names, it’s teeming with players who can provide immense value to the right teams. Whether it’s a veteran cornerback like Carlton Davis or an emerging linebacker like Jamien Sherwood, the smartest teams will find their edge in these hidden gems. The key is to look beyond the headlines and focus on players who can thrive in the right scheme.