2025 MLB Fantasy Baseball: Hidden Gems and Underrated Players to Watch

Hidden Gems for Your 2025 MLB Fantasy Baseball Roster

As spring training games heat up, baseball enthusiasts and fantasy managers alike are eagerly fine-tuning their draft lists. While the first few rounds often grab the spotlight, savvy managers know that championship wins are forged in the middle rounds. Here, we delve into some unheralded players who could be the key to your fantasy success in 2025.

Junior Caminero, 3B, Tampa Bay Rays

Why He's a Must-Have:

• Raw Power: Caminero boasts an 80-grade power potential, making him a rare find outside the top 50 picks.
• Performance Metrics: Last season, he led Triple-A in exit velocity (with a minimum of 150 batted balls). His MLB stint showed a Barrel rate and hard-hit rate better than the 70th percentile.
• Environment: Playing at George M. Steinbrenner Field, a hitter-friendly venue, and batting in the heart of the order could propel him to a top-25 overall season.

Expert Insight: “Expect a big breakthrough from Caminero in 2025.” -- Tristan H. Cockcroft

Christian Yelich, OF, Milwaukee Brewers

Why He's a Must-Have:

• Proven Track Record: Despite a shortened 2024 season, Yelich maintained a stellar .909 OPS with 11 home runs and 21 stolen bases.
• Health Update: Offseason surgery has addressed his back issues, and he’s expected to be ready for Opening Day.

Expert Insight: “Yelich doesn't need to return to his 2018 NL MVP form to get back to top-50 fantasy status.” -- Eric Karabell

Christian Walker, 1B, Houston Astros

Why He's a Must-Have:

• Consistency: Over the past three seasons, Walker has averaged 32 home runs, 94 RBI, 81 runs, and five steals with a .250 batting average.
• New Environment: Moving to a homer-friendly ballpark could boost his already impressive stats.

Expert Insight: “Being able to wait for Walker allows fantasy managers to focus on other lineup spots early in drafts.” -- Todd Zola

Taylor Ward, OF, Los Angeles Angels

Why He's a Must-Have:

• Five-Category Contributor: While not a standout in any single category, Ward consistently contributes across all five.
• Undervalued: Despite being projected as the 52nd-most-valuable hitter, Ward is often drafted 100+ spots below his value.

Expert Insight: “Old, boring veterans are perpetually undervalued—and they’re also perpetually the key to winning leagues.” -- Derek Carty

Draft Strategy Tips

• Focus Mid-Round: Championship wins are often determined by shrewd mid-round picks rather than top-tier selections.
• Monitor Spring Training: Early games provide valuable insights into players’ readiness and potential performance boosts.
• Value Over Hype: Players like Ward demonstrate that overlooked veterans can offer significant value.

By targeting these underrated players and employing strategic drafting, you can position your 2025 MLB fantasy baseball team for championship success.