NFL QB Reclamation Projects: Lessons from Darnold, Mayfield, and Smith

The Rise of the Reclamation Quarterbacks

The NFL has seen a growing trend of quarterbacks reviving their careers after initial struggles. Players like Sam Darnold, Baker Mayfield, and Geno Smith have turned their fortunes around with new teams, sparking discussions about what it takes to succeed in a second chance.

Recent Examples of Success

• Sam Darnold: After a rocky start with the Jets, Darnold found new life with the Vikings in 2024, posting above-average stats in EPA per dropback and success rate. His resurgence is a testament to the power of a fresh start.
• Baker Mayfield: Once written off after his stint with the Browns, Mayfield flourished with the Buccaneers, leading them to consecutive playoff appearances and posting career-best numbers.
• Geno Smith: After years as a backup, Smith emerged as a reliable starter for the Seahawks, proving that persistence and the right environment can lead to success.

Keys to a Successful Reclamation

1. Talent and Potential: Most reclamation projects were high draft picks with untapped potential. Their physical tools and competitiveness set them apart from late-round picks.
2. The Right Environment: A well-run organization with a supportive coaching staff can unlock a quarterback's potential. Teams like the Vikings and Buccaneers have proven to be ideal landing spots.
3. Low Expectations: When quarterbacks are signed as bridge players or backups, they often thrive without the pressure of being the franchise savior.
4. Strong Offensive Support: Elite receivers and smart play-calling can elevate a quarterback's performance. Players like Justin Jefferson and Mike Evans have played pivotal roles in these revivals.

Who Could Be Next?

Looking ahead to 2025, quarterbacks like Justin Fields, Daniel Jones, and Jameis Winston could be prime candidates for a career revival. Teams like the Falcons, Rams, and Vikings offer the right mix of talent and opportunity to facilitate a turnaround.

Teams to Watch

• Atlanta Falcons: With a strong receiver in Drake London, the Falcons could be a great spot for a veteran QB to reboot their career.
• Los Angeles Rams: Sean McVay's system has a history of maximizing quarterback potential, making the Rams an attractive destination.
• Minnesota Vikings: The Vikings' offensive success with Darnold makes them a prime landing spot for another reclamation project.

Conclusion

Quarterback reclamation projects are a fascinating aspect of NFL team-building. By identifying the right players and providing them with the right environment, teams can turn former disappointments into valuable contributors. As free agency approaches, the stories of Darnold, Mayfield, and Smith serve as blueprints for success.